FINES OF 337,000 LEI, FOR ABUSIVE CLAUSES IN LENDING CONTRACTS
BURSA 03.07.2017

ADINA ARDELEANU, RAMONA RADU (translated by Cosmin Ghidoveanu)
 
mărește imaginea
Ianfred Silberstein is an administrator at Easy Credit and strategy consultant with the NBR
     * Some Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) have been forced to return to their borrowers the money collected illegally, as well as to freeze their advertising campaigns until their activity complies with the law *  The ANPC has also audited Easy Credit, managed by Ianfred Silberstein, consultant with the NBR *  Dan Suciu, NBR: "Ianfred Silberstein is no longer on the payroll since 2015, but he can work as a project-based consultant" *  Provident fined 40,000 lei
       The non-banking financial institutions have been fined a total of 337,000 lei, following the audit conducted by the National Consumer Protection Agency (ANPC), between May 8th, 2017 - June 16th, 2017, according to a report of the ANPC, published by the Parakletos Association.

     The watchdog revealed the abusive terms of the NBFC lenders and the illegalities committed by these companies.

     Aside from fines, the ANPC has issued warnings, has requested the remedy of the shortcomings, as well as putting and end to the incorrect commercial practices.

     Also, the ANPC has asked some NBFCs to repay to the borrowers the amounts that they had collected without any legal basis.
     The ANPC also ruled the freezing of the advertising campaigns of NBFCs until their compliance with the law.
     The authority has audited the loan agreements, with or without a mortgage, concluded by the non-banking financial companies between February 01st, 2017 - May 05th, 2017.
     The non-bank financial institutions which the ANPC audited and uncovered irregularities at include Provident Financial România, Easy Credit 2 All and Easy Credit 4 All, Ocean Credit or Legal Credit.
     Irregularities concerning the advance repayment clause, at Easy Credit
     The ANPC inspectors have also uncovered irregularities at Easy Credit, which the press recently wrote about and reported that it is managed by Ianfred Silberstein, former legal advisor and even legal executive at the NBR and current consultant of the NBR.
     In a report on the abusive interest rates and clauses practiced by NBFCs, Antena 3 presented the statement of Mr. Silberstein that he is not in a conflict of interest, even though he is the head of an institution that is overseen by the NBR.
     Mr. Silberstein claims that he is not an employee of the NBR, which is why he doesn't think the connection of their company with the IFNs can represent a source of conflict of interest.
     Silberstein claims that people don't get informed and sign things too easily and superficially, without reading contracts in advance, which is why they don't find out about those clauses that could prove disadvantageous for them later.
     Lawyer Gheorghe Piperea wrote on Facebook, that the conflict of interest is involved in "blatant and can be seen from space": "Not only is a consultant or advisor of the NBR is an employee of the NBR (or similar), because he is getting a (significant) compensation from the NBR and has positions in most all of the institutions shepherded by the NBR, but Mr. Silberstein is still the president of the Association of Banking Legal Advisors, organizer of one or more banking law seminars. The latest (and probably last) banking law seminar held for judges and prosecutors was organized and held in April at the Romanian Banking Institute under the patronage of Mr. Silberstein.
     In that seminar, (...) it was said, among other things, that the big issue of the banking system was not the criminal, deceitful and abusive of the practices and behavior of the bankers, but the low level of consumer education. (...) Mr. Silberstein said that, in the A3 report, that there is nothing wrong with a penalty interest rate of 0.5% per day of delay as long as the debtor did not open their eyes when they signed the agreement. Like Manole the builder said (ed. note: according to the press, the NBR governor Mugur Isărescu delivered reports, under the code name Manole, as an informant to the former political police, prior to 1989) - a contract is a contract, right? The suckers, the naïve should pay, as they're adults".
     Dan Suciu, the spokesperson of the NBR, told us, on Friday, that Ianfred Silberstein has no longer been on the payroll of the NBR since 2015, but he sometimes serves as a consultant on projects.
     In the same Antena 3 report, Dan Suciu is saying that NBR can't intervene against the interest rates and penalties of 80-7700% a year practiced by non-financial lenders, as they are "commercial" matters.
     The ANPC has found that the Easy Credit 2 All and Easy Credit 4 All of Constanța have violated the legal provisions concerning the early reimbursement of loans.
     Article 40 of the Emergency Government Ordinance din OUG 52/2016 stipulates: "Consumers have the right, at any time, to fully or partially carry out the obligations that are theirs as part of loan agreement before its ending. In that case, the consumer has the right to a reduction of the total cost of the loan, with that reduction consisting of the interest rate and the costs pertaining to the amount repaid in advance for the period between the date of the early repayment and the date the loan agreement ends".
     According to the ANPC, the customers of Easy Credit were expected to announce in writing to the company the intention of making an advance repayment, because otherwise, the lender might construe the depositing of those amounts as an intention of paying in advance the interest for a period of a maximum of half a year.
     The ANPC report mentions: "The economic operator has expressed its willingness to notify all debtors engaged in similar ongoing contracts about the need to eliminate a written request in the case of advance partial repayments, within 15 days from the date of the communication of the present document".
     Provident charged different commissions for the same service, according to the ANPC
     The ANPC has issued a fine of 40,000 lei, in the case of Provident Financial România, amid the fact that the amount of the commission charged was different from one contract to the next, even though the service provided to the consumer was the same.
     The ANPC report mentions: "It hereby clearly follows that these amounts did not represent a unified commission as defined by the law, as being a commission fee which has an identical value to all consumers, which requests from the professional an additional service, regardless of the type of financial product owned".
     In the case of a complaint filed with the ANPC, a consumer signed three contracts on October 7th, 2016, on June 10th, 2016 and April 15th, 2016 thus meaning that three different prices were charged for that service, (910 lei, 1495,45 lei and 1190,77 lei), the report by the institution states.
     Also, the loan application review fee and the single fee must be set as a fixed amount, as the same amount is charged to all consumers with the same type of loan at the same lender, the ANPC notes.
     The report of the ANPC is sizeable, and irregularities have been uncovered at tens of non-bank lenders.
     At Fast Finance IFN, the regulator found that its ads provided information which was misleading to consumers, namely information concerning the currency of the loan (the NBFC does not actually lend in Euros), and the duration of the loan is not 48 hours, but rather the period for the review of the granting decision.
     According to the ANPC, Telecredit IFN SA advertises an interest rate of 1.2%, without mentioning whether it applies per day/week/month/year.
     The ANPC inspectors found that the customers of TBI Credit IFN were also required to sign insurance policies. In the case of one specific loan agreement, an insurance policy of 1,167 lei was signed, of which only 262 would be paid to the insurer, while the rest represented a fee.
     The ANPC states: "As it follows from the description above, consumers, in particular retirees and vulnerable individuals, without specialized knowledge, sign these agreements, and the employees of the professional - the NBFC - have every interest in convincing them to sign these insurance policies with the preferred insurer because almost 80% of the amount of the insurance, on which the consumer pays interest, represents the commission of the agent".
     Parliamentarian Liviu Balint of the Chamber of Deputies, proposes the capping of the Annual Effective Interest rate for NBFCs that are charging absolutely ridiculous rates.
     Liviu Balint said, according to ProTv: "We have to protect the consumers, because they end up losing their homes. There are 10-12 countries in Europe where there are such restrictions."
     The legislative draft is going to be formulated after the parliamentary holiday. 
 

 
Readers' comments    [ add a comment ] 
Aceeasi sectiune (English Section)
CEC BANK CHAIRMAN REACTS TO THE STATEMENTS OF LUCIAN ISAR:
THE WEAKNESS OF THE MANAGEMENT OF THE BSE IN ACTION
IN 2012, THE OPENING OF THE BIDS FOR THE PRIVATIZATION OF THE PLANT TOOK PLACE IN THE PRESENCE OF THE PRESS
Ediții precedente
Newsletter Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn RSS
Jurnal Bursier
27.07.2017
BVB
     * Lichiditate de doar trei milioane de euro
       Ședința de tranzacționare de la mijlocul săptămânii a fost marcată de o lichiditate redusă, de numai 13,85 mi¬lioa¬ne de lei (3,03 milioane euro), de peste trei ori mai mică față...  detalii
27.07.2017
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Acțiunile tranzacționate la piețele din Europa au cres¬cut ieri, pentru a doua zi la rând, datorită rezultatelor pozitive anunțate de companii.  detalii
26.07.2017
BVB / LICHIDITATE DE PESTE 140 MILIOANE DE EURO
     * 95% din rulajul total, realizat prin finalizarea ofertei derulate de instituția bancară
       Piața Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a fost dominată, în ședința de tranzacționare de ieri, de raportarea încheierii ofertei publice derulate cu obligațiuni lansate de "Unicredit Bank".  detalii
26.07.2017
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Acțiunile companiilor listate la bursele din Europa au urcat ieri, pentru prima oară în ultimele patru zile, în baza rezultatelor financiare anunțate de companii.  detalii
25.07.2017
BVB
     * Săptămâna a debutat cu scăderi, pe o lichiditate de doar 6 milioane de euro
      * Titlurile "SIF Banat-Crișana", cele mai lichide
       Opt din indicii Bursei de Valori București (BVB) au încheiat prima ședință de tranzacționare a săptămâ¬nii în teriroriul negativ, în contextul în care a fost înregistrat un volum de...  detalii
25.07.2017
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Acțiunile companiilor listate la bursele din Europa au scăzut ieri, sectorul auto consemnând cele mai mari pierderi, după ce Guvernul de la Berlin a confirmat că autoritățile de concurență...  detalii
Cotații Internaționale

Curs Valutar

Curs valabil din data de 26 iulie 2017
1 Dolar australian...
1 Leva bulgărească...
1 Dolar canadian....
1 Franc elvețian...
1 Coroană cehă...
1 Coroană daneză...
1 Liră egipteană...
1 Euro...
1 Liră sterlină...
100 Forinți maghiari...
100 Yeni japonezi...
1 Leu moldovenesc...
1 Coroană norvegiană...
1 Zlot polonez...
1 Rublă rusească...
1 Coroană suedeză...
1 Liră turcească...
1 Dolar S.U.A...
1 Rand sud-african...
1 Real brazilian...
1 Renminbi chinezesc...
1 Rupie indiană...
100 Woni sud-coreeni...
1 Peso mexican...
1 Dolar neo-zeelandez...
1 Dinar sărbesc...
1 Hryvna ucraineană...
1 Dirham emirate arabe...
1 Kuna croată...
1 Bahtul thailandez...
1 Gram aur...
1 DST...
AUD
BGN
CAD
CHF
CZK
DKK
EGP
EUR
GBP
HUF
JPY
MDL
NOK
PLN
RUB
SEK
TRL
USD
ZAR
BRL
CNY
INR
KRW
MXN
NZD
RSD
UAH
AED
HRK
THB
XAU
XDR
3,1028
2,3330
3,1381
4,1008
0,1753
0,6136
0,2188
4,5628
5,1101
1,4902
3,5086
0,2160
0,4909
1,0709
0,0655
0,4768
1,1015
3,9248
0,3008
1,2370
0,5811
0,0610
0,3506
0,2211
2,9140
0,0378
0,1522
1,0685
0,6156
0,1172
157,2684
5,4986
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
click aici pentru cursurile pieței valutare - istoric
English Section
26.07.2017
SOURCES CLOSE TO THE SITUATION:
     * Sources: "A large segment of the price asked for the Mariott building represents the loan contracted by Grand SRL and guaranteed by the state"
     * Dedeman wants to buy the Marriott complex, according to our sources
     * AFI Europe has announced that Dedeman is scrapping plans to buy AFI 4 and 5
       The Austrians of Strabag are asking for 140 million Euros for the building the Marriott hotel of Bucharest is operating in, according to sources close to the deal.  details
25.07.2017
SPECIALISTS:
     * The BRUA project can no longer be funded, after Hungary announced that it would stop on the Hungarian territory, our sources are saying
       The BRUA pipeline, which was supposed to go through Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary and Austria, will have the same fate as Nabucco, meaning it won't be built, some market specialists think.  details
24.07.2017
CEC BANK CHAIRMAN REACTS TO THE STATEMENTS OF LUCIAN ISAR:
     * (Interview with Mr. Radu Grațian Ghețea, the president of CEC Bank)
     * CEC Bank intends to end this year with a three figure profit
     * CEC Bank chairman: "When the EBA makes moves and finds an easing of interest rates is possible, then that will happen over here as well"
     * Radu Ghețea: "In the case of Romcab, we have begun the foreclosure, we have foreclosed some of the collaterals and we will continue to foreclose on others"
       CEC Bank intends to end this year with a three figure profit, Radu Grațian Ghețea, the chairman of the bank told us in a sizeable interview.  details
22.07.2017
MIRCEA URSACHE, ASF:
     * Ursache: "Romcab is required to file the same reports during its restructuring period as it would during normal operation"
       "Romcab" (MCAB) has the same reporting obligations, during the restructuring period, that it does during its regular operation, said Mircea Ursache, vice-president of the Financial...  details
19.07.2017
MIRCEA URSACHE CONFIRMS:
     * Ursache: "We are asking the market operator to comply with corporate governance"
     * In fact, the investigation targets Lucian Anghel, the president of the BSE, because he is the one that can summon the board
       The Financial Oversight Authority is conducting an analysis of the manner of summoning and unfolding of the Board of Directors of the Bucharest Stock Exchange Mircea Ursache, vice-president of the...  details
17.07.2017
     The Association of Brokers has taken a stand against the exclusion of the BURSA newspaper from the guest list of the official events of the Bucharest Stock Exchange, reported on Friday.  details
14.07.2017
THE WEAKNESS OF THE MANAGEMENT OF THE BSE IN ACTION
     The officials of the Bucharest Stock Exchange avoid explaining why they are excluding BURSA from events.  details
13.07.2017
AFTER FOUR YEARS AT THE HELM OF THE BSE
     * The Board of the Stock Exchange has been waiting for Ludwik Sobolewski's answer for about three weeks now
       Ludwik Sobolewski, who called himself the Alpha Male of the stock market, has received from BSE president Lucian Anghel, an offer for a new term as CEO of the Bucharest Stock Exchange, which...  details
11.07.2017
     The commotion caused by the old news that BURSA published, which were revealed as if they were new, by the Rise Project "investigators", drew attention to the detail, (that we presented...  details
11.07.2017
JOURNALISTS WITHOUT MORAL BOUNDARIES
     The news that PSD president Liviu Dragnea is the shareholder of Tel Drum S.A., which does road infrastructure works and which was awarded all the contracts of the County Council of Teleorman in...  details
08.07.2017
MINISTRY OF PUBLIC FINANCES (MFP):
     * MFP: "CEC Bank has decided to terminate the loan agreements of Romcab, after the company refused to allow the bank access to its raw materials warehouses"
     * MFP: "The decisions to lend the money as well as the allocation of the exposure limits by Romanian insurers and international insurers were done based on the financial statements made available by the company"
       "Romcab", which filed for insolvency in February, had inventories of 493 million lei at the end of 2016, according to the certification report received by EximBank, according to a response...  details
08.07.2017
IN 2012, THE OPENING OF THE BIDS FOR THE PRIVATIZATION OF THE PLANT TOOK PLACE IN THE PRESENCE OF THE PRESS
     * Chimcomplex has announced it has made a bid
     * Sources: "PCC did not participate in the call for bids"
     * Gheorghe Piperea: "We have several offers, both for the five asset packages of Râmnicu Vâlcea, as well as for other packages"
       Whereas in 2012, the privatization of "Oltchim" generated a media blitz, as the opening of the bids occurred with the participation of the press, yesterday, the closing of the call for...  details
05.07.2017
     The Italian Chamber of Deputies recently organized the conference called "Italy's public debt in the Eurozone", which saw experts in the restructuring of public debt, academics,...  details
04.07.2017
     * A new blunder, trademark Toma Petcu: "Energy companies do not have investments in the pension funds "
       While Agriculture Minister Petre Daea causes amusement through his speeches about sheep, Energy Minister Toma Petcu seems to be the champion of blunders.  details
03.07.2017
FINES OF 337,000 LEI, FOR ABUSIVE CLAUSES IN LENDING CONTRACTS
     * Some Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) have been forced to return to their borrowers the money collected illegally, as well as to freeze their advertising campaigns until their activity complies with the law * The ANPC has also audited Easy Credit, managed by Ianfred Silberstein, consultant with the NBR * Dan Suciu, NBR: "Ianfred Silberstein is no longer on the payroll since 2015, but he can work as a project-based consultant" * Provident fined 40,000 lei
       The non-banking financial institutions have been fined a total of 337,000 lei, following the audit conducted by the National Consumer Protection Agency (ANPC), between May 8th, 2017 - June 16th,...
  details
.