THE COURT RULED THAT SOME CONTRACTS CONCLUDED BY CELL PHONE COMPANIES INCLUDE ABUSIVE CLAUSES
BURSA 11.12.2017

EMILIA OLESCU (translated by Cosmin Ghidoveanu)
 
mărește imaginea
     *  The Bucharest Court of Appeal Bucharest yesterday ruled that RCS&RDS has abusive clauses in its contracts
     *  The ANPC has also won the initial lawsuit against Telekom România
     *  Vodafone has lost the case in the court of last instance against the ANPC
       The Courts have decided that some contracts concluded by the telephony companies contain abusive clauses. The Court rulings were rendered last year, as well as in 2016, but the argumentations have been formulated relatively recently.
     It is abnormal for some telephony operators to interpret < < unlimited > > as < < unlimited with a certain limit > >, said Paul Anghel, the president of the National Consumer Protection Authority (ANPC), when asked by BURSA about the clauses in question.
     He mentioned the decisions rendered by the Court of Bucharest and the Bucharest Court of Appeal, respectively, in two lawsuits brought by the ANPC against telephony operator RCS&RDS.
     The argumentations of the courts emphasize that the contracts in question "omit essential information", and do not specify potential restrictions applicable to the "Optim Nelimitat" plan. "The contract, addendum, general and special terms do not inform consumers about the levels which, if exceeded by consumers, allow the phone company to suspend or restrict the service". Subscribers to the RCS&RDS "Digi Mobil Optim Nelimitat" subscription receiving an SMS are not allowed to replace an addendum to the contract "and those unlimited minutes may not be capped at 3,000", the courts ruled.
     One of the contractual clauses identified as abusive concerns the criteria used by RCS&RDS to identify a call as fraudulent. They are as follows:
     "- calls distributed evenly in time;
     - constant calls, made between 00:00- 07:00; - low number or lack of received calls;
     - the existence of a high number of calls to certain destinations or to distinct destinations only;
     - the average call duration;
     - the existence of some hints concerning the use of the phone service for commercial purposes and particularly the running of call-center activities, promoting or selling services via phone, polling, etc.;
     - complaints from some operators or individuals concerning the telephony service which is the object of this contract".
     By analyzing the quoted article it was found that the provisions concerning the situations in which the generation of a large number of calls to other networks are considered frauds are not sufficiently clear, by not allowing users to know the situations and the conditions which can lead to the restricting of mobile telephony services.
     The use of a deceitful commercial practice by resorting to the omission of information violates the law no. 363/2007, and is a fineable offense.
     The courts have also identified abusive clauses as per the law no. 193/2000.
     In one the cases brought against RCS&RDS, the Bucharest Court of Appeal rendered a definitive ruling which states that the telephony operator has the following abusive clauses in its contracts: "RCS&RDS has the right to ask the beneficiary to return the landline phone if no telephony traffic occurs for two months. The beneficiary expressly and unconditionally pledges to return to the operator the landline and the afferent SIM card fix, if applicable, to the extent where there has been no phone traffic over a period of two months, on the date of the request by the operator, and in the event of the failure to deliver on time the goods in the state it has received them in, the beneficiary pledges to pay to the operator, as a criminal clause, the amount of 1 (one) Euros for each day of delay, and the terms of the acceptance certificate will also be applicable, on a case by case basis. (...) RCS&RDS is in no way responsible for the (direct or indirect losses), the loss of opportunities or business opportunities or for the profits that the beneficiary or the third parties that he has legal relations with has missed out on, due to the failure to function or the inadequate functioning of the services which are the objects of those specific clauses. The only remedy which the beneficiary is entitled to request is to have their subscription proportionally reduced according to the periods of non-functioning".
     The representatives of RCD&RDS did not provide their opinion on the matter by the time the newspaper had gone to print.
     * The ANPC has also won the trial lawsuit against Telekom România
     The Bucharest County Court has ruled, in a lawsuit against Telekom România Communications, that the clause which shows that the petitioner gets a disproportionate discount compared to the compensations which need to be paid by the consumer, creating a significant imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties: "The compensations for the termination of the contract concerning the package of services on grounds of mutual fault or upon the customers' decision prior to the expiration of the minimal period amount to 223.2 Euros with VAT (more than 18 months left until the expiration of the minimum period), of 167.4 Euros with VAT (between 13 and 18 months left until the expiration of the minimal period), 111.6 Euro with VAT (between 7 and 12 months left until the expiration of the minimal period), and 55.8 Euros with VAT (less than 6 months left until the expiration of the minimal period)".
     The court requires the petitioner to modify all ongoing contracts of adhesion, as well as eliminate the abusive clause from the pre-made contracts of the same kind, according to the decision published on the portal of the court.
     The resolution will be rendered in the trial court, and the representatives of Telekom România told us that they are awaiting for the definitive resolution: "At the present time, the lawsuit is not in its final stage. We are talking about a first ruling of the Court of Bucharest and we are awaiting for a definitive solution in this particular case".
     * Vodafone lost the lawsuit against the ANPC through a definitive ruling
     Vodafone lost the lawsuit against the ANPC Romania through a definitive ruling. The Bucharest Court of Appeal found the existence of an abusive clause which states: "The contract expires upon the request of the customer through a written notification addressed to Vodafone at least 30 days before the desired cancellation date. The customer pledges to pay all debts coming due and a compensation in the event the contract were to expire prior to the minimum contractual period".
     Other clauses which the court has identified as abusive include:
     "- The deactivation of the Roaming service for Vodafone E-mail Plus;
     - the deactivation of the monthly extra features for mobile internet while on roaming;
     - the change of the monthly extra options while on roaming;
     - roaming limits;
     - the deactivation of the roaming service for mobile internet".
     The representatives of Vodafone România have declined to comment on this subject.
     In the reported cases, the sanctions which are required are provided in the specific legislation - Government ordinance concerning consumer protection 21/1992, Law no. 363/2007 concerning unfair practices, Law 193/200 concerning abusive practices and Emergency Government Ordinance 34/2014 concerning the conclusion of remote contracts.
     According to Paul Anghel, the clauses identified by the courts as abusive, have to be removed from the contracts, and the potential prejudice caused by these clauses has to be quantified and the consumer has to be compensated.
     PNL senator Daniel Cătălin Zamfir, the president of the economic commission, recently participated in hearings in the specialized commission, concerning the clauses in the telephony contracts.
     After the hearings, he wrote on his Facebook page: "Are we being robbed when it comes to the mobile telephony and internet bills? Is it legal to charge a fee for the changing of the services operator? Is it mandatory to notify the subscriber prior to the expiration of the subscription? Are the unlimited minutes and data traffic sold as such really unlimited? Well, all these things have been discussed in the presence of ANCOM president Sorin Grindeanu, of ANPC president Bogdan Pandelică, of ANPC CEO Paul Anghel, of CNA president Laura Georgescu, of the representatives of the Competition Council and of the representative of the mobile telephony operators, less those of Vodafone".
     According to the liberal senator, all the representatives of the aforementioned state authorities have committed before the Commission to intervene in the cases of abuses which were reported and to resume those discussions in the beginning of 2018, in order to identify the concrete steps made by each individual institution and the passed measures. 
 

 
Readers' comments    [ add a comment ] 
Trimite părerea ta.
Nume (maxim 50 caractere)
E-mail (optional)
Titlu (maxim 50 caractere)
Mesaj
 
REGULAMENTUL MESAJELOR
Acord
Prin trimiterea opiniei ne confirmați că ați citit regulamentul de mai sus și că vă asumați prevederile sale !
Aceeasi sectiune (English Section)
Calendarul BURSA 2018
Ediții precedente
Newsletter Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn RSS
Jurnal Bursier
20.07.2018
BVB
     * Circa 64% din rulaj, dat de transferurile cu acțiunile Romgaz
     
     Toți indicii Bursei de Valori București (BVB) au înregistrat scăderi, în penultima ședință de tranzacționare a săptămânii,...  click să citești tot articolul
20.07.2018
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Bursele din Europa au scăzut ieri, din cauza evoluțiilor sectorului minier, afectat de declinul cotațiilor metalelor.
     Titlurile grupului minier global "Anglo American" Plc s-au depreciat...  click să citești tot articolul
19.07.2018
BVB
     Piața principală a Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a încheiat ședința de tranzacționare de la mijlocul săptămânii în teritoriul negativ, majoritatea cotațiilor terminând ziua în scădere, pe fondul...  click să citești tot articolul
19.07.2018
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Bursele din Europa au urmat un curs pozitiv, ieri, în baza rezultatelor financiare anunțate de companii.
     Titlurile producătorului suedez de echipamente de rețea "Ericsson" AB s-au...  click să citești tot articolul
18.07.2018
BET-FI, SINGURUL INDICE ÎN SCĂDERE
     Opt din cei nouă indici ai Bursei de Valori București (BVB) au cunoscut aprecieri moderate, în ședința de tranzacționare de ieri, pe fondul unui volum de numai 26,2 milioane de lei, sub valoarea...  click să citești tot articolul
18.07.2018
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Acțiunile tranzacționate la bursele din Europa au avut o evoluție mixtă ieri, investitorii fiind atenți la rezultatele anunțate de corporațiile listate.  click să citești tot articolul
Cotații Internaționale

Curs Valutar

Curs valabil din data de 19 iulie 2018
1 Dolar australian...
1 Leva bulgărească...
1 Dolar canadian....
1 Franc elvețian...
1 Coroană cehă...
1 Coroană daneză...
1 Liră egipteană...
1 Euro...
1 Liră sterlină...
100 Forinți maghiari...
100 Yeni japonezi...
1 Leu moldovenesc...
1 Coroană norvegiană...
1 Zlot polonez...
1 Rublă rusească...
1 Coroană suedeză...
1 Liră turcească...
1 Dolar S.U.A...
1 Rand sud-african...
1 Real brazilian...
1 Renminbi chinezesc...
1 Rupie indiană...
100 Woni sud-coreeni...
1 Peso mexican...
1 Dolar neo-zeelandez...
1 Dinar sărbesc...
1 Hryvna ucraineană...
1 Dirham emirate arabe...
1 Kuna croată...
1 Bahtul thailandez...
1 Gram aur...
1 DST...
AUD
BGN
CAD
CHF
CZK
DKK
EGP
EUR
GBP
HUF
JPY
MDL
NOK
PLN
RUB
SEK
TRY
USD
ZAR
BRL
CNY
INR
KRW
MXN
NZD
RSD
UAH
AED
HRK
THB
XAU
XDR
2.9496
2.3800
3.0322
4.0037
0.1798
0.6245
0.2243
4.6549
5.2150
1.4325
3.5498
0.2403
0.4866
1.0777
0.0632
0.4490
0.8298
4.0128
0.2985
1.0420
0.5919
0.0581
0.3520
0.2108
2.7028
0.0395
0.1514
1.0925
0.6294
0.1199
156.9985
5.6105
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
click aici pentru cursurile pieței valutare - istoric
English Section
13.07.2018
Russia World Cup
     The final tournament of the World Football Cup will end with a gala representation, the duel between Croatia and France. France, the with the most expensive players in the tournament, has met the expectations, Croatia is the biggest surprise the of the competition.  click here to read the entire article
09.07.2018
FOOTBALL AND MONEY
     Cristiano Ronaldo (33 years old) had several hits over the last few days, even though in the final tournament of the World Championship he failed to exceed expectations, as Portugal was eliminated in the round of eight.  click here to read the entire article
05.07.2018
     The world is intensely preparing for a water crisis, the most important resource for human life. The signs, on a continental and global level, that there is a water problem are increasingly clear.  click here to read the entire article
02.07.2018
     The Bursa Construcțiilor magazine, published by the BURSA press group, has taken the first step in the third decade of existence and has awarded, in this year's Gala, no fewer than 20 awards of excellence, to some of the most important associations in the sector, as well as to companies that have stood out through their activity.  click here to read the entire article
27.06.2018
A VOTE FOR AN UNFORGETTABLE SUMMER
     In the plenum joint meeting of the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate, which will be held today starting at 14:00, will be debated and put up for vote the vote of no-confidence against the government submitted by 152 members of the opposition.
     The document which incriminates the failures of the Dăncilă government has been read in the Parliament on Monday, June 25th.  click here to read the entire article
25.06.2018
     Even without the court ruling rendered in first instance by the High Court of Cassation and Justice in the lawsuit of the fictitious hiring at the Child Protection Department of Teleorman the focus on getting all the institutional levers under the - informal, but all the more important - authority of Liviu Dragnea. But, after his conviction on June 21, this trend will speed up. But only through this kind of concentration of power can the president of the Chamber of Deputies hope to change not only the balance of power - which is already favorable to him, even though nothing is final in politics -, but the legislation based on which he has been sentenced, so that he gets exonerated of any legal responsibility. Or, when the powers of the state are concentrated in the hands of one man, democracy, even though it may be only a façade, moves aside to be replaced by autocracy. And in Romania, the temptation of autocracy, hidden under the veil of illiberalism, is more powerful than it has ever been, after the fall of communism. Could this be just an accident owed to the meteoric apparition of Liviu Dragnea?  click here to read the entire article
19.06.2018
     The Romanian Constitution:
     Art. 80 - The role of the president
     (1) The Romanian president represents the Romanian government and is the guarantor of national independence, unity and territorial integrity.
     (2) The Romanian president must watch for the compliance with the Constitution and the good functioning of the public authorities. For that purpose, the president serves as a mediating entity between the powers of the state, as well as between the state and society.  click here to read the entire article
12.06.2018
     The reunion scheduled today between Donald Trump and Kim Jong-un is taking place in Singapore due to the relative neutrality and the security this city-state provides. Singapore is one of the few countries that still hosts a North-Korean embassy, and many of the deals of the Kim regime were conducted here, according to the foreign press.  click here to read the entire article
05.06.2018
     "It is a good thing that the public doesn't understand the functioning of our banking and monetary system, because otherwise I think there would be a revolution in the streets by dawn".
     HENRY FORD, founder of the American automotive industry

     Fed up with subsidizing the commercial banks with their own money, the Swiss, mobilized through the "Sovereign Money" initiative, have proposed the organization of a Referendum which will be held on Sunday, June 10th 2018 - is a historical referendum, revolutionary for the banking industry, of international resonance -, by which the initiators want to amend the Constitution, which would impose to the commercial banks to grant loans only within the limits of the bank's money, forbidding them to issue scrip money and ensuring the monopoly of the Confederation (of the Swiss state) on issuance of money free of debt.  click here to read the entire article
23.05.2018
     The "pension apocalypse is coming"! The more or less qualified keep talking in the written press, TV and on the radio. The uncertainty is being preserved - deliberately by some, by the government members out of pure stupidity!  click here to read the entire article
16.05.2018
GABRIELA MIHAELA VOICILĂ, THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT MINISTER:
     Where there are many entrepreneurs there is creation, where there are many women entrepreneurs there is divine creation, says Gabriela Mihaela Voicilă, state secretary in the Ministry for the Business Environment, Trade and Entrepreneurship (MMACA). In her opinion, entrepreneurship means joy, a better situation, but less time for the family: "Taken together, entrepreneurship means achievements (...) Every one of us needs validation, for having built, having created something".  click here to read the entire article
14.05.2018
IN THE LAWSUITS AGAINST THE BANKS
     * Piperea: "In the Andriciuc case, the EU Court of Justice has not limited its argumentation to the CHF, but expanded it to cover any currency for which the debtors weren't hedged"
     The courts in the country have begun ruling in favor of borrowers and freezing the value of the European currency at the exchange rate valid on the date the loans were originated, in the lawsuits brought against the banks.  click here to read the entire article
09.05.2018
IN THE ROMANIAN BANANA REPUBLIC...
     The urge "Mircea, act like you're working!", back in the days of the so-called revolution of December 1989, was brought back recently by a new "director".
     We are talking of course, about the meeting between NBR governor Mugur Isărescu, and a government "delegation" led by chamber of deputies chairman Liviu Dragnea, together with PM Viorica Dăncilă.
     Sources from within the PSD, quoted by ziare.com, have claimed that, "in the meeting with the NBR governor, Liviu Dragnea seemed to be looking for a way out, and he seems confused, as he didn't expect his decisions to lead to such effects in the economy".  click here to read the entire article
08.05.2018
     Liviu Dragnea's insistence in moving the Romanian embassy from Tel Aviv, to Jerusalem, feeds an older, widespread confusion. Much older. Politically, Jerusalem has been divided from the first presence of the Judeans on the lands of the Palestinians, since back in the days of Abraham and Abimelec. "The indivisible Jerusalem" wanted by Benjamin Netanyahu is a spiritual creation.
     Definitely, pilgrims and locals claim that Jerusalem has a geography, meaning that the city would be compatible with the cardinal points and that is why Palestinians, Israelis and people overall, including those of the UN, EU and the US, speak about Eastern Jerusalem and Western Jerusalem, without anybody being surprised that that is happening at the center of the world, where the god of the Judeans began his creation, starting from the very rock from which later Archangel Gabriel raised Mohammed to visit Heaven, the same place of origin where one of the seven angels "and showed me the Holy City, Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God." (Apocalypse, 21: 10), where God is one of the same.  click here to read the entire article
03.05.2018
     Financial fair play is a concept that comes from the world of soccer. The notion is simple, don't spend more than you earn in a month, or in a year, regardless of what shareholder, mogul or investor enters the business.  click here to read the entire article
.