Electrica Furnizare
CONFERINȚA "Fondurile Europene" - Ediția a IX-a
FINANCE MINISTER CONFIRMS WHAT BURSA REPORTED FIVE MONTHS AGO:
BURSA 03.08.2017

Emilia Olescu (translated by Cosmin Ghidoveanu)
 
mărește imaginea
     * PNL senator Daniel Cătălin Zamfir asks for a "list of shame" of banks that don't pay taxes
     * According to information obtained by BURSA, between 2011-2015, banks in Romania paid 1.3 billion lei (288 million Euros) in taxes
       Public Finance Minister Ionuț Mișa says that almost three quarters of banks operating in Romania haven't paid profit tax in the last few years. With that statement, the head of the Finance Ministry confirms what BURSA reported five months ago.
     "Romanian banks only pay taxes if they want to, as they have a very complicated profit reporting system", we wrote on March 7th, 2017, in the article " Romanian banks - a vehicle for multinationals to take money out of the country", quoting official, reliable sources. The article we published caused noise on the banking market, as some of the heads of the commercial banks expressed their outrage at the information we published, but some of them declined to send us officially their opinions on the subject.
     The finance minister said a few days ago, on a TV show, that "we have 70% of Romanian banks which in the last five years haven't paid any profit tax".
     According to information obtained by BURSA, between 2011-2015, banks in Romania paid 1.3 billion lei (288 million Euros) in taxes.
     Liberal Daniel Cătălin Zamfir, president of the economic commission in the Senate, is asking for the list of banks that don't pay taxes.
     He said: "Tomorrow morning (ed. note: today) I will go to the Senate and I will ask the Finance minister, through a letter, to publish the list of shame for the banking sector and non-financial companies that don't pay taxes, the same way that they have presented the list of individual taxpayers who didn't pay their taxes. So we can know, for instance, last year, when they reported a profit of 1 billion Euros, how much did the banks pay in taxes? And why do they not pay taxes? How do they dodge the law? Is there a loophole in the legislation? Then we should finish it! We have submitted that draft law that would resolve the issue of profits being transferred abroad, but people in the Finance ministry, who are working on that text, don't, even though we have asked them to get it done faster".
     Five months ago, our sources told that there are financial institutions that haven't paid profit tax in ten years, and posted a loss in all that period. Banks are using the special legislative provisions dedicated to the banking sector to avoid paying profit tax, the quoted sources say, and they explained that it has to do with the unlimited deductibility of expenses incurred through the sale of non-performing loans (NPL).
     Our sources gave us an example: "Let's say that a bank has made a profit of 100 million Euros and has sold a package of 200 million Euros worth of NPLs. In general, a bank will sell the non-performing loan portfolios at 5-7% of their face value, but according to a study, the median in the system is 11%. Thus, on 200 million Euros worth of NPLs, the bank makes 22 million, posting a loss of 178 million Euros. That loss is fully deductible, according to the legislation in effect. Thus, the institution in question ends the financial year with a loss of 78 million Euros, after the expense with the sale of the NPL portfolio is subtracted from the profit. The problem is that losses are carried over into the next fiscal years, from one year to the next, until the bank breaks even, with that being a cyclical phenomenon.
     Thus, a bank that posts a profit in a year, in reality doesn't pay any taxes at all, because the posted profit is offset by the losses from the previous years. This is a trick used by banks to avoid paying taxes to the state".
     According to the existing figures, between 2011-2015, out of 46 banks, 19 paid a profit tax, in some of these years, and the others never paid any taxes, our sources said in closing.
     In the first quarter of this year, the National Bank of Romania (NBR) reported a net profit of the banking system of 1.237 billion lei, up YOY from 1.16 billion lei.
     The 37 banks have posted last year a total profit of over 433 million lei, or around 960 million Euros, compared to slightly higher than 1 billion Euros - the banks' total profit in 2015.
     * The information published by BURSA according to which a bank was found by ANAF to have unpaid taxes has also been confirmed by the Ministry of Finance
     Romanian banks have massively sold off non-performing loans (NPL), over these last few years, and they will continue that process in order to clean up their balance sheets, as announced by their officials. The NPL ratio decreased to 9.36%, in the first three months of the current year, from 13.52% - the level of non-performing loans in Q1 2016. The representatives of the banking system and the heads of the NBR have announced that they intend to bring the NPL ratio down to 6% - the median ratio in Europe.
     The manner in which banks sell NPL portfolios has now come to the attention of the ANAF, care which is conducting specialized audits in the banking system.
     BURSA announced, four months ago, that following such audits, the ANAF had uncovered that one of the banks operating in Romania had unpaid taxes, according to ANAF officials.
     ANAF officials have told us, answering a question asked by BURSA: "The General Department for the Management of Major Taxpayers of the ANAF has included in its program for 2016 partial fiscal audits in companies in the banking system, of which one has been completed, whereas the others are ongoing. The tax inspection entities of the General Department for the Management of Major Taxpayers of the ANAF have found the taxpayers owed additional amounts in taxes".
     A few days ago, Finance Minister Ionuț Mișa also confirmed that statement and he further said: "We have also focused on big companies. We have dared to go on the offensive and to conduct audits at banks. One of them has been completed. At one in the banks of Romania they ended up reducing the fiscal loss of 650 million lei and was established an additional tax liability of 104 million lei. That loss was artificially created and, through that audit, we managed to bring to the surface 650 million plus another 104 million. By reducing the loss, in the coming years that bank will pay profit tax. It will no longer compensate the profit tax with the previous losses".
     BURSA reported last year, that the ANAF has initiated audits among banks, by identifying irregularities which have serious consequences.
     Ionuț Mișa, who at the time was the director of the General Department for the Management of Major Taxpayers of the ANAF, told us, back then, that one such example would be the sale of loan bundles by banks. In October 2016, he explained: "Banks set up loan portfolios, in which they include performing and non-performing loans alike, which they sell at far lower prices to companies that would handle the collection of the unpaid portions of those loans in the years following their sale. There are cases where performing loans have also been sold, and those assets were bundled with the non-performing ones. It is undisputable that banks have an interest in selling loans that are not overdue. It is possible that banks are doing that to move their profits to another fiscal jurisdiction. The profits made on those performing loans must be recorded as profits in Romania, but since they are integrated in those bundles of non-performing loans, the profits are recorded elsewhere, so that banks reduce their profits and avoid the pertaining taxes.
     There are situations where banks are majority shareholders in the affiliated companies that they are selling those loans to. But there are also cases where those companies aren't affiliated with those banks, but that doesn't mean that they have any connection with the banks. Because there are situations where the companies in question can be identified as being shareholders in other companies, which would in turn have banks as their majority shareholders. We know that such practices exist, but we do not have access to such information and it is very hard to get to it. We are hoping that now, with the agreements concerning access to financial information, we will be able to prove these practices, because they do exist, even if they are found three or four links down the chain. We have indications that such practices exist in banks too, from various sources, even the media. Bundles of loans of 100 million Euros have been sold for 5-7 million Euros. The difference of 95-93 million Euros would represent a deductible expense. They have been booked as losses, which would mean that banks have reduced their profit".
     Sources close to the situation have told us that financial institutions sell non-performing loans within the group (to a company in which the bank is a shareholder), to an offshore or to a company where in which a former manager of the bank is a shareholder. The quoted sources explained: "The bank sells to an off-shore loans of 100 million Euros, for a price of 7 million, with a recovery rate of 35-40%, and the off-shore in question concludes an agreement with the bank to continue collecting its installments, offering it a commission of 1.8%. As a result, the profit of 28 million Euros (35 million recouped less the 7 million paid upon purchase) goes to other countries, instead of staying here.
     * Florin Georgescu, BNR: "The low prices at which the banks have sold those NPLs justifies the audit of the ANAF"
     Sales of household NPLs have accelerated starting with 2015, and the average sale price of those loans between 2008 and 2016 was 10% of the face value of the portfolios, with significant fluctuations from one year to the next (between 2% and 16%), said Florin Georgescu, first deputy governor of the NBR, in a presentation made at the end of March.
     He said that the sale price for non-performing loans that belonged to individual borrowers has fluctuated, between 2009 and 2012, between 2% and 7%, and in 2013-2016 - between 7% and 16%.
     The prices at which NPLS have been sold was, on average, 8.5% of the face value of the portfolios between 2014 and 2016, with significant fluctuations from one year to the next (between 3% and 9%).
     In other words - as it was known, even though some bankers and debt collectors refuse to admit it -, banks have sold non-performing loans at discounts of up to 98%.
     In this context, Florin Georgescu said that "The low prices at which the banks have sold those NPLs justifies the audit of the ANAF in terms of the legality of the potential fiscal optimizations performed through these operations".
     Nicolae Cinteză, the head of the Oversight Division of the National Bank of Romania (NBR), gave us assurances, in 2015, that performing loans may not be sold, even though borrowers have constantly complained about that very thing happening, just a few days after they were taken out.
     According to data from the Central Bank, 91.4% of the total banking assets are privately owned, and the weight of those that are owned by foreigners is 90.9% of the total. 

     * Mișa: "We have completed our audits in two banks, of which one is a major player, really heavy one, in the system"
     The Finance Minister said yesterday, on TV: "On December 31st, 2016, out of 46 banks, 31 posted losses. That loss amounted to 9.8 billion lei. There are 15 banks that have paid profit tax in the last few years, and that includes those that have paid taxes in just one year. The total amount of taxes paid by these banks in those five years is 1.7 billion lei. The imbalance is already obvious. We are dealing with all kinds of operations of so-called tax optimization".
     Ionuț Mișa mentioned that fiscal secrecy prevents him from naming the banks that paid taxes or those that didn't, but stressed that the government has extended the audits it had initially launched in the banking sector: "We have initiated new audits in banks and we will expand them, because we are talking about significant amounts of tax receipts. We have completed our audits of two banks, of which one is a major player, really heavy one, in the system. We have a bank which had ten losing years. We wonder why it is still active in Romania?"

 
 

 
Readers' comments    [ add a comment ] 
Aceeasi sectiune (English Section)
THE ANPC STARTS THE REVOLUTION ON THE BANKING MARKET
AFTER FINDING THAT THE STRATEGY OF RAIFFEISEN BANK WAS DISHONEST
AT THE INVESTIGATIVE COMMISSION OF THE ACTIVITY OF THE ANRE
RADU CRĂCIUN, APAPR, ABOUT THE INVESTMENT OF PRIVATE PENSION FUNDS IN DIGI, A COMPANY WHICH HAS CRIMINAL ISSUES:
UNICREDIT WARNS THAT THE ROMANIAN GOVERNMENT IS REPEATING MANY OF THE MISTAKES THAT HAVE LED TO THE RECESSION OF 2009-2010
AFTER BEING FORCED TO MOVE THE BRD NĂSTASE ȚIRIAC TROPHY TOURNAMENT TO BUDAPEST
Ediții precedente
Newsletter Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn RSS
Jurnal Bursier
24.10.2017
BVB
     * Titlurile BRD și "Banca Transilvania" și-au continuat deprecierea, deși au fost cele mai tranzacționate
       Piața Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a înregistrat, în prima ședință de tranzacționare a săptămânii, o lichiditate de 36 milioane de lei (7,82 milioane de euro), în creștere față de ședința de...  detalii
23.10.2017
BVB
     * Acțiunile "Banca Transilvania" și BRD - deprecieri de peste 2%
       Piața Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a înregistrat, în ultima ședință de tranzacționare a săptămânii, o lichiditate de 21,05 milioane de lei (4,57 milioane de euro), în scădere față de ședința de...  detalii
23.10.2017
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Bursele din Europa s-au înscris pe un curs pozitiv vineri, în baza rezultatelor financiare peste așteptări anunțate de companii printre care "Ericsson" și "Volvo" AB din Suedia.  detalii
20.10.2017
BVB
     Ședința din penultima zi de tranzacționare a săptămânii a înregistrat o lichiditate de 32,82 milioane de lei, mai mare decât cea înregistrată miercuri, de 31 milioane de lei, dar sub media zilnică...  detalii
20.10.2017
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Acțiunile companiilor listate la bursele din Europa au scăzut ieri, din cauza escaladării tensiunilor politice din Spania.  detalii
19.10.2017
BVB
     * Acțiunile "Aerostar" - avans de aproape 15%, după semnarea memorandumului cu "Raytheon International Defence System" privind înzestrarea armatei cu sisteme Patriot
       Piața Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a înregistrat, în ședința de tranzacționare de ieri, o lichiditate de 31 milioane de lei (6,75 milioane euro), sub media zilnică a acestui an (48,13 milioane...  detalii
Cotații Internaționale

Curs Valutar

Curs valabil din data de
1 Dolar australian...
1 Leva bulgărească...
1 Dolar canadian....
1 Franc elvețian...
1 Coroană cehă...
1 Coroană daneză...
1 Liră egipteană...
1 Euro...
1 Liră sterlină...
100 Forinți maghiari...
100 Yeni japonezi...
1 Leu moldovenesc...
1 Coroană norvegiană...
1 Zlot polonez...
1 Rublă rusească...
1 Coroană suedeză...
1 Liră turcească...
1 Dolar S.U.A...
1 Rand sud-african...
1 Real brazilian...
1 Renminbi chinezesc...
1 Rupie indiană...
100 Woni sud-coreeni...
1 Peso mexican...
1 Dolar neo-zeelandez...
1 Dinar sărbesc...
1 Hryvna ucraineană...
1 Dirham emirate arabe...
1 Kuna croată...
1 Bahtul thailandez...
1 Gram aur...
1 DST...
AUD
BGN
CAD
CHF
CZK
DKK
EGP
EUR
GBP
HUF
JPY
MDL
NOK
PLN
RUB
SEK
TRL
USD
ZAR
BRL
CNY
INR
KRW
MXN
NZD
RSD
UAH
AED
HRK
THB
XAU
XDR
3,0574
2,3514
3,1001
3,9684
0,1793
0,6178
0,2215
4,5988
5,1585
1,4922
3,4382
0,2248
0,4898
1,0866
0,0681
0,4769
1,0579
3,9154
0,2855
1,2262
0,5897
0,0602
0,3467
0,2062
2,7252
0,0386
0,1474
1,0660
0,6127
0,1180
160,6332
5,5117
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
click aici pentru cursurile pieței valutare - istoric
English Section
23.10.2017
THE ANPC STARTS THE REVOLUTION ON THE BANKING MARKET
     The National Consumer Protection Agency (ANPC) recently fined no less than 15 commercial banks, on charges of misleading advertising, according to sources close to the situation.  details
23.10.2017
     * The price interval in which investors will be able to subscribe is 12 lei - 15.5 lei/share
     * The IPO will end on November 2nd
       The subscription period for the IPO of Transilvania Broker de Asigurare (symbol: TBK), will begin on October 24th. According to the prospectus published on Friday by the company, the subscription price range will be 12 lei - 15.5 lei/share.  details
19.10.2017
AFTER FINDING THAT THE STRATEGY OF RAIFFEISEN BANK WAS DISHONEST
     * Daniel Zamfir: "It has been proven that Raiffeisen has cheated people. There is nothing left to debate"
     * Bogdan Pandelică: "The order for the cessation of the unfair practice of Raiffeisen Bank has been issued, I will sign it in a few days"
       All the banks that have granted CHF loans will be audited by the National Consumer Protection Authority (ANPC), its chairman Bogdan Pandelică, announced yesterday in the Economic Commission of the Senate.  details
18.10.2017
OVIDIU DEMETRESCU, ARBA:
     * The management of the company accepted two applications that were sent in late, for the elections of October 26th, claiming they were submitted "within reasonable delays"
     * "I think that we are embarrassing ourselves, by the mere fact that we were able to interpret the law in such a way", said Ovidiu Demetrescu
     * "Demetrescu: "ASF and BVB should react, in the case of Electrica, if they had a management with a free spirit"
       The directors of "Electrica" (EL) violated the law when accepting the applications backed by the government for the elections of the new management, recorded eight minutes after the deadline from the convening notice, claiming they were submitted "within a reasonable delay", says Ovidiu Demetrescu, the president of the Romanian Association for Good Management (Asociația Română de Bună Administrare - ARBA).  details
16.10.2017
EXCLUSIVE
     * "The US and Saudi Arabia - the main sponsors of terrorism in the world"
     * (Interview with His Excellency, Mr. Hamid Moayyer, ambassador of the Republic of Iran in Romania)
       Donald Trump, the United States president, must decide by October 15th whether or not he will certify if Iran has followed the terms of the nuclear agreement signed in 2015 by Iran and six major western powers.  details
12.10.2017
EARTHLY LAWS, IGNORED ON THE BSE PLANET
     The Bucharest Stock Exchange (BVB), the operator of the Romanian capital market, still stands by the nonsensical claim made by its former CEO Ludwik Sobolewski, that his contract expired on August 21st, but not his mandate.  details
12.10.2017
AT THE INVESTIGATIVE COMMISSION OF THE ACTIVITY OF THE ANRE
     * Sources: PSD has four names for the head of the ANRE
     * Rumored names: Florentin Pandele, mayor of Voluntari, Iulian Iancu, president of the Industries Commission, former prime-minister Sorin Grindeanu and deputy Eugen Nicolicea
       Niculae Havrileț, the president of the National Authority for Regulation in the Energy Sector (ANRE), together with other members of the Regulatory Committee of the ANRE, will arrive before the Commission for the Investigation of the activity of the ANRE.  details
11.10.2017
RADU CRĂCIUN, APAPR, ABOUT THE INVESTMENT OF PRIVATE PENSION FUNDS IN DIGI, A COMPANY WHICH HAS CRIMINAL ISSUES:
     Mandatory private pension funds which have invested in Digi Communications, the parent company of RCS&RDS, which was indicted on money laundering and offering bribes, have taken this operating risk into account, by offering a lower price in the IPO, Radu Crăciun, member on the Board of Directors of the Romanian Association of Privately Managed Pensions (APAPR).  details
09.10.2017
     President of BURSA Press Group, Florian Goldstein (MAKE), participated, as speaker, on September 26th, at a debate regarding the future of the European Union, in Brussels, at the invitation of Group of the European People's Party.
     The subject of the debate can be synthesized in four questions:
     1. Would it be recommendable for the EU Non-Eurozone States to adopt Euro currency?(...)
     -------------
     Question nr.1 answers given by my fellow citizens are divided, and this summer polemic between the Euro MP Theodor Stolojan and Daniel Daianu (member of the Romanian National Bank Board of Directors) in the financial newspaper BURSA has shaped up the idea we could adopt Euro anytime (given the condition of maintaining the macroeconomic balances), an idea opposed to the one claiming Euro adoption should wait till the convergence criteria would be fulfilled.  details
09.10.2017
UNICREDIT WARNS THAT THE ROMANIAN GOVERNMENT IS REPEATING MANY OF THE MISTAKES THAT HAVE LED TO THE RECESSION OF 2009-2010
     * Vasilescu: "There are many crystal ball readers, even in the banking system"
     * UniCredit estimates that the leu will continue to weaken against the Euro to 4.6-4.7, in the first quarter of 2018, and that the policy rate will increase to 2.5%
       UniCredit Bank analysts are issuing a warning that the Romanian government is repeating many of the mistakes that have led to the recession of 2009-2010. The quoted experts are mentioning both the fiscal policy that is risky for the economy, as well as the fact that the leu will significantly weaken in 2018, and the deficit may increase to 3.7%. Among other things, the UniCredit report issued on Friday predicts an EUR/RON exchange rate of 4.7 and a policy rate of 2.5%, for the beginning of next year.  details
05.10.2017
AFTER BEING FORCED TO MOVE THE BRD NĂSTASE ȚIRIAC TROPHY TOURNAMENT TO BUDAPEST
     * Ilie Năstase: "If I was Țiriac, I would sue Mugur Isărescu"
       PNL senator Daniel Zamfir, president of the Budget Commission in the Senate, a vocal critic of the banking system, of the NBR and of its governor is adamant about bringing up the activity of the NBR from all angles.  details
03.10.2017
     * The BSE may be taken off the watchlist
     * FTSE only noted improvements when it comes to stock lending, while the liquidity requirement has not yet been met
     * Poland, upgraded to the emerging market status
     * Mongolia and Nigeria, removed from the watchlists
       The Bucharest Stock Exchange (BSE) remains a frontier market, for at least a year, after, on Friday night, FTSE Russell did not give promote it.  details
02.10.2017
     * Iulian Iancu: "We shouldn't stand out by being silent in Brussels and be forced to give natural gas to the neighboring countries, by taking it away from our industrial consumers"
     * Emil Calotă: "If we do not take action, the natural gas stored by the Romanian producers will remain unused, because there will be far cheaper imported gas available"
       The National Authority for the Regulation of the Energy Market (ANRE) has asked for the reconsideration of gas storage policies in Romania to be made a priority, Emil Calotă, the vice-president of the ANRE recently said, in the debates in the Industry Commission of the Romania Parliament about the Draft Law concerning the approval of the Government Emergency Ordinance no.64/2016 for the amendment and completion of the Law of Electricity and of natural gas no. 123/ 2012.  details
29.09.2017
LUCIAN ANGHEL:
     We can't expect Romania to be upgraded to the emerging market status right now, BSE president Lucian Anghel said yesterday, as FTSE Russell will publish today its annual classification report.  details
28.09.2017
     Central European Media (CME), the owner of Pro TV, is currently in negotiations to sell the four TV stations it still holds in Central and Eastern Europe, according to Echo 24, which quotes several concerned sources.  details
.