MIHAI FERCALĂ, SIF TRANSILVANIA:
BURSA 12.03.2014

Adina Ardeleanu (Translated by Cosmin Ghidoveanu)
 
mărește imaginea
       The shares of SIF3 Transilvania fell 7.78%, in the session which followed the announcement of its management that it is proposing the increase of the share capital using last year's profit and the granting of free shares, instead of dividends.
       The executive president of SIF Transilvania, Mihai Fercală, explained to us, in an interview, the reasons behind this proposal not to distribute the profits. According to him, the granting of free shares is more advantageous than the distribution of the entire profit.

 
     Reporter: It would seem that the investors have not been pleased with the recent proposal of the company to distribute free shares and to keep the profit within SIF Transilvania, judging by the evolution of the price of the SIF3 stock. How would you comment on that?
     Mihai Fercală: I don't know whether the drop of the price was caused by the proposal of SIF Transilvania or by other events which have led to the drop of all the stocks on the Bucharest Stock Exchange.
     The operation of increasing the share capital by offering free shares - one new share for each old share held -is clearly more profitable to investors compared to the situation where we would have completely paid out the net profit in the form of dividends.
     Had we done that, that would have meant a dividend of 17 bani per share.
     If we give free shares, assuming the General Shareholder Meeting accepts the proposal, and the share capital gets doubled, and the trading price will fall by half, even though we don't know for sure that the market will react like that or not, then a new share received free of charge will be worth 30 bani instead of 17.
     Anybody that runs the numbers all the way through can find that the proposal of the directorate and of the Supervisory Board SIF Transilvania is clearly more beneficial to the shareholders.
     I haven't seen any investors operating on the stock market complain publicly in the case of Banca Transilvania, which has offered free shares instead of dividends for years. No one came out to say they are unhappy with that policy.
     Furthermore, by keeping the money within SIF Transilvania, we have the possibility of radically restructuring our portfolio, which was affected over the last few years, due to the payment of very high dividends, of about 85-90% of the net profit. The remaining amount is not enough to make a radical restructuring of the portfolio by replacing non-performing assets with performing ones.
     Reporter: What restructuring do you have in mind?
     Mihai Fercală: Unfortunately, we still have in our portfolio lots of companies that are not listed, companies which we have owned since the initial allocation of 1992, when we were created as a Private Ownership Fund. Those companies are very hard to make profitable, very hard to take public and very hard to sell.
     In many companies, we are not majority shareholders, because we have started off from a 30% initial stake. If the majority shareholder doesn't want to take the company public, we have nothing to do and we are held captive, with those stakes and with those assets, without having the possibility to sell them at prices that would give us a minimum profit - at the face value at least.
     Given that kind of circumstances, we need significant financial resources, which we can only get by making obtain from that profit, which would allow us to buy other assets in the sectors we have identified as having growth potential this year and in the coming years, such as energy, drugs, commodities processing, financial industry, banking. Without sizeable investments in the acquisition of listed assets, in the near future, our portfolio will not generate particular sales. If we follow the theory that we are distributing alarmingly high levels of the profit that we make in the form of dividends, we would essentially be planning to liquidate the SIF in the next 2-3 years.
     The moment we've finished selling the liquid assets, we will no longer have anything else to sell, and when that time comes, not only will the SIF not be making any profit, but the question arises whether the SIF can continue to operate or not.
     Reporter: Are you considering grouping assets in holding structures, like SIF Banat Crișana and SIF Moldova did?
     Mihai Fercală: We can think of many things, but we don't know what they would be useful for. We could, for instance, group into a holding all the stakes we have in tourism. Unfortunately, I don't know if that would help increase the profitability of those assets, even though we have made significant investments in tourism. All the companies in this segment, are profitable, but the profit they can afford to distribute to the SIF, as their majority shareholder, is rather small. So, even if I were to unite all of them into a holding, I don't know what we could do. This year, we will try to sell some of our assets in the tourism sector, the ones that are functional, and we hope we will earn some appropriate proceeds from those sales, which would allow us to invest in other sectors.
     Reporter: This year, you have listed three companies from your portfolio on Sibex and not on the BSE. What were the reasons?
     Mihai Fercală: There was no special reason for us to choose Sibex as opposed to the BSE. Perhaps just the fact that the people at Sibex moved a lot faster than those at the BSE. Our interest was to take a few our assets public on the alternative trading system. This was a response to the need to meet certain legal requirements concerning the risk in our portfolios, namely to lower the weight of unlisted assets to less than 20% of the portfolio.
     Reporter: What is their current weight?
     Mihai Fercală: Right now, they are less than 20%, following these listings. Essentially, we are fully compliant with the all the prudential requirements of the Financial Oversight Authority, as well as within the norms concerning the management of risk at SIF Transilvania.
     Reporter: Do you have any other listings planned in the coming period?
     Mihai Fercală: As we come to the conclusion that more companies can be listed on the alternative trading system, we may do so. Right now, on the occasion of the annual statement, we are conducting a review of all the stakes that we have and one or two months from now we will uncover other companies that could get listed.
     Reporter: You recently sent a letter to Dan Radu Rușanu, who was, at the time. the president of the Financial Oversight Authority, in which you spoke about discrepancies between the legislation and the regulations of the ASF, as well as about the talks concerning the holding limit at the SIFs. Mr. Mircea Ursache also told us that he is postponing the proposals until 2015, as this is an electoral year.
     Mihai Fercală: I don't think that this kind of talks has anything to do with the electoral years or not. We have to start off from a different element, not from what an authority, a broker, or an investor may want, but from what the SIFs actually are. They are private companies. In private companies, the amendment of the articles of incorporation, setting the rules of the game are exclusively the responsibility of the shareholders. You can't have someone from the outside set a restriction on a company or eliminate one. I am wondering what the difference is between SIF Transilvania and Petrom. Can the ASF come in at Petrom and set a restriction or not, or if Petrom has any stipulations in its articles of incorporation that are compliant with the law, can the ASF come in and say "take those stipulations out!"? I don't think so.
     If we constantly try, through various interests, to attack the articles of incorporation of privately owned companies it means that we are violating the regulations of the European Union, which stipulate that the amendment of the articles of incorporation, the setting of restrictions are the exclusive rights of the shareholders of the company. I want to remind you that, a few years ago, SIF Transilvania has proposed the raising of the holding limit from 1% to 5%. At the time, the CNVM could not do it, we had to go to court and by the time the court came up with a solution, the Parliament issued a law and changed the holding limit. We did not dispute the regulation because in actuality it gave us what we wanted, but even that time, the intervention of the Parliament was unconstitutional, from my point of view.
     Reporter: The ASF has also proposed the amendment of the quorum requirements at the SIFs.
     Mihai Fercală: There is the framework, the Law no. 31/1990, which stipulates the quorums in companies for conducting ordinary and extraordinary shareholder meetings, but the limits apply only "if the articles of incorporation have don't have differing stipulations".
     The law does not prohibit companies from setting their own quorum requirements, through their articles of incorporation.
     In a situation like that, it's not the ASF that needs to step in, the ASF has no rights to propose legislative drafts. It can however propose to a ministry, a parliamentary group or to the government to come up with a legislative initiative. As long as the law stipulates the limits or their manner of amendment, any intervention means a measure or censorship of the shareholders' rights. The fact that it is being said that the General Shareholder Meetings can't be held only has two explanations - either there isn't everything being done to reach the quorum, or the shareholders don't want that holding limit to be changed and that is why they are not showing up for the General Shareholder Meetings where it is being discussed.
     Furthermore, the ASF has to decide whether the SIFs are companies or collective investment bodies and treat them accordingly.
     If the SIFs are collective investment bodies, then we pay fees of 0.1% a month, but certain provisions don't apply to us, or we are regular companies and we don't pay any fees to anybody.
     Reporter: Are you considering legal action against the ASF, given these discrepancies?
     Mihai Fercală: Yes, because the ASF has not answered a series of criticisms we have filed against the decisions made by the Authority. We have a complaint with the administrative court. If we win, that's fine, if we don't - we will live with it. The court will decide who is right, us or the ASF. When I am addressing an institution of the state and I am asking for something, it means I am noticing some dysfunctionalities and I am asking them to comply with the law. If it is I who have misunderstood the law, perhaps the court will explain to me how it works.
     Reporter: What is your opinion on the scandal of the ASF and the fact that its chairman and another one of its members were arrested in the "Carpatica" scandal?
     Mihai Fercală: I am sorry that it has come to something like this. I don't know the charges that are being brought against the president of the ASF - if they are real or not -, but, at any rate, this thing can't be good for the stock market and for the notion of regulation itself in general, if the leaders of the supervisory institutions are being charged with breaking the law themselves. I am sorry that something like this has happened. I repeat, I don't know whether Mr. Rușanu is guilty or not, I don't know the details of the case, but since the court decided that he should be arrested, that means there is some evidence that needs to be investigated and heard and I suppose the court will issue a ruling.
     Reporter: Concerning the investment program, did you take into consideration the listings that the state has announced for this year? Do you expect them to stick to that schedule?
     Mihai Fercală: Let's hope that they will, but I can see that surprises are beginning to appear, like the one at Hidroelectrica.
     Reporter: Thank you! 

     
     "This year, we will try to sell off some of our assets we have in the tourism sector".
     
     "The people at Sibex moved a lot faster than those at the BSE".
     
     "I haven't seen any investors operating on the stock market complain about Banca Transilvania, which has offered free shares instead of dividends for years. No one came out to say they are unhappy with that policy".
     
     "We have filed an administrative complaint (ed. note: against the ASF)".

 
 

 
Readers' comments    [ add a comment ] 
1.  si in engleza
    (mesaj trimis de nicolas în data de 12.03.2014, ora 19:39)  
 esti la fel de bun economist si in engleza ca si in romana,,,s-au gindit sa te traduca si pe tine ca pe ceausesc..africanii...Mai da cum gestionezi tu actiunile investotorilor...ca sa faci dividende la moameni...ne spui si noua,,prostii care am cumparat actiuni la sif 3 dorind o dobinda mai buna decit banca,,,,mare MISEL,,,esti bade,,,chiar o sa urmaresc...evolutzia ta viitoare,,sunt sigur ca bine nu o sa-ti fieee..


 
2.  Free shares cheaper than nothing !
    (mesaj trimis de doru stoian în data de 14.03.2014, ora 14:12)  
 
 Romania gratis = priceless !


 
  2.1.   All = whole Romania, for 1 USDNew = 0,5 Yuro !  (răspuns la opinia nr. 2 )
    (mesaj trimis de doru stoian , in data de 14.03.2014, ora 14:15)
 
 
 China & India too expensive !


 
Aceeasi sectiune (English Section)
FOLLOWING THE ARTICLE PUBLISHED YESTERDAY IN BURSA
THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION CRITICIZING THE MONOPOLY IN THE TRADING OF NATIONAL GAS
THE DIGI OFFER HAS ENDED AT A PRICE OF 40 LEI/SHARE, AND THE LISTING IS SCHEDULED FOR MAY 16
SUBSCRIPTION RATE OF 2783%, ON THE UNGUARANTEED RETAIL TIER UNTIL YESTERDAY
ANDREEA LAMBRU, THE PRESIDENT OF HIDROELECTRICA:
AN EXPLANATION ON BITCOIN AND THE FUTURE OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOOGIES
Ediții precedente
Newsletter Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn RSS
Jurnal Bursier
23.05.2017
SIBEX
     La Sibex, debutul săptămâni nu a fost unul foarte încurajator, interesul pentru derivate continuând să fie unul modest.  detalii
23.05.2017
BVB
     * Titlurile "Fondul Proprietatea", cele mai lichide
       Șapte dintre indicii Bursei de Valori București (BVB) au încheiat ședința de tranzacționare de ieri în apreciere, în contextul în care a fost înregistrat un volum de tranzacționare de 36,5 milioane...  detalii
22.05.2017
SIBEX
     După două săptămâni în care, de fiecare dată, Sibex nu a reușit să treacă pragul de 100 de contracte, a treia săptămână din luna mai a adus, cu chiu cu vai, depășirea acestui prag.  detalii
22.05.2017
BVB
     * Indicii au crescut, pe un rulaj de aproape 15 milioane euro
       Piața principală a "Bursei de Valori București" (BVB) a fost dominată, în ședința de tranzacționare de vineri, de cinci transferuri de tip "deal", realizate cu acțiuni "Fondul...  detalii
22.05.2017
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Acțiunile tranzacționate la bursele din Europa au urmat un curs pozitiv vineri, recuperând ceva teren după declinul din zilele anterioare, generat de turbulențele politice din SUA.  detalii
19.05.2017
SIBEX
     La Sibex, apatia a fost cuvântul de ordine în prima jumătate a penultimei ședințe a săptămânii.  detalii
Cotații Internaționale

Curs Valutar

Curs valabil din data de 22 mai 2017
1 Dolar australian...
1 Leva bulgărească...
1 Dolar canadian....
1 Franc elvețian...
1 Coroană cehă...
1 Coroană daneză...
1 Liră egipteană...
1 Euro...
1 Liră sterlină...
100 Forinți maghiari...
100 Yeni japonezi...
1 Leu moldovenesc...
1 Coroană norvegiană...
1 Zlot polonez...
1 Rublă rusească...
1 Coroană suedeză...
1 Liră turcească...
1 Dolar S.U.A...
1 Rand sud-african...
1 Real brazilian...
1 Renminbi chinezesc...
1 Rupie indiană...
100 Woni sud-coreeni...
1 Peso mexican...
1 Dolar neo-zeelandez...
1 Dinar sărbesc...
1 Hryvna ucraineană...
1 Dirham emirate arabe...
1 Kuna croată...
1 Gram aur...
1 DST...
AUD
BGN
CAD
CHF
CZK
DKK
EGP
EUR
GBP
HUF
JPY
MDL
NOK
PLN
RUB
SEK
TRL
USD
ZAR
BRL
CNY
INR
KRW
MXN
NZD
RSD
UAH
AED
HRK
XAU
XDR
3,0393
2,3315
3,0159
4,1875
0,1720
0,6125
0,2258
4,5600
5,2949
1,4772
3,6634
0,2220
0,4868
1,0875
0,0719
0,4670
1,1440
4,0774
0,3091
1,2533
0,5916
0,0631
0,3650
0,2185
2,8359
0,0371
0,1547
1,1101
0,6130
164,7405
5,6314
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
click aici pentru cursurile pieței valutare - istoric
English Section
22.05.2017
     * Three foreign players - Abu Dhabi Investment Council, VARDE and a Canadian investment fund - are rumored to be interested in Bancpost
      * The bank is also attractive to some lenders operating in Romania
       Aside from the banks in Romania interested in acquiring Bancpost, there are also apparently some foreign entities that have set their sights on Bancpost, according to some market sources. They are...  details
19.05.2017
FOLLOWING THE ARTICLE PUBLISHED YESTERDAY IN BURSA
     BCR yesterday apologized to one of its customers, after BURSA reported that their performing loan with no arrears is registered with the Cadastre Office as having been assigned to a company...  details
18.05.2017
THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION CRITICIZING THE MONOPOLY IN THE TRADING OF NATIONAL GAS
     * BRM accuses the intention to nationalize the trading of natural gas
     * The commission for industries and services: "The European model: one exchange for the transparent, competitive and non-discriminatory trading of natural gas"
     * Sources: The European Commission and the PEGAS pan-European platform for the trading of natural gas warns that the amendments are not compatible with the competition regulations
     * Virgil Popescu, PNL: "We will be asking for the draft law to be sent back to the commission"
       The European Commission reacted on Tuesday, after the deputies of the Commission for Industries and Services have passed a series of amendments to the Natural Gas Law, according to which the gas...  details
17.05.2017
     * Transactions of 62.82 million lei in the first trading day
     * "The EBRD has participated in the offer and it has been allocated the biggest block of shares", the DIGI CEO said
     * Bulgac: "We have considered the listing in Amsterdam or Warsaw as well"
       Shares of DIGI Communications (DIGI) have been listed yesterday, on the Bucharest Stock Exchange, closing the session at 41.2 lei/share, up 3% over the price in the IPO, after closing at 41.7...  details
16.05.2017
     * The ASF has recorded the DIGI shares
       * UPDATE 10:12 DIGI stock opened at 41.7 lei/share
     Digi Comunications (DIGI) opened today's trading session on the BSE, above the closing price in the IPO, at 41.7...  details
15.05.2017
     SIF2 Moldova wants to conduct public buyback offer for its own shares and has already submitted the prospectus for that offer with the Financial Oversight Authority (ASF), according to an...  details
15.05.2017
COPY-PASTE ANSWERS
     * The draft law concerning the approval of the Memorandum of Understanding concluded between the Romanian state and The Rompetrol Group NV got a negative opinion from the Constitutional Commission in the Senate
       * The draft law concerning the approval of the Memorandum of Understanding concluded between the Romanian state and The Rompetrol Group NV got a negative opinion from the Constitutional Commission...  details
12.05.2017
THE DIGI OFFER HAS ENDED AT A PRICE OF 40 LEI/SHARE, AND THE LISTING IS SCHEDULED FOR MAY 16
     * The lawyer says that the ASF must observe ex officio the market manipulation, in the case of the use of bank guarantee letters
     * Piperea: "The law punishes even manipulation attempts, and the fine can go as high as 275,000 lei per day"
     * Raiffeisen secretively replaced an announcement concerning the reallocation between tiers, posted on the BSE website
       The Financial Oversight Authority (ASF) needs to urgently refer the matter to itself concerning a potential market manipulation, in the case of the use of bank guarantee letters in the Digi...  details
11.05.2017
UNPRECEDENTED SITUATION
     * RCS&RDS has been prosecuted just as the IPO was ongoing
     * Some investors forced to withdraw
     * Before the subscription, the EBRD had made a commitment to subscribe, but it had asked the company to make commitments to fight bribery and corruption
       Whether it meant to or not, the National Anti-Corruption Department was a major player in the offer for the listing of Digi Communications, the parent company of RCS&RDS.  details
10.05.2017
SUBSCRIPTION RATE OF 2783%, ON THE UNGUARANTEED RETAIL TIER UNTIL YESTERDAY
     * Some brokers claim that the granting of loan in order to buy stocks skews the demand
     * The ASF shirks any responsibility concerning this offer
     * On May 8th, 2017, RCS&RDS was officially notified by the DNA that it is a suspect in the ongoing investigation
     * Investors can withdraw their subscriptions until 17:00
       Few of the investors in the Digi Communications offer got scared off by the prosecution of two of the RCS&RDS executives and withdrawn their subscriptions, after the amendment of the prospectus...  details
09.05.2017
ANDREEA LAMBRU, THE PRESIDENT OF HIDROELECTRICA:
     * The Ministry of Energy is preparing the change of the privatization method, according to Mrs. Lambru
       Andreea Lambru, the new chairman of the supervisory Board of Hidroelectrica, doesn't expect the company to get listed this year, hinting that time is needed for the Ministry of Energy to change...  details
05.05.2017
     * (Interview with Mr. Dorel Goia, majority shareholder in Teraplast)
     * Goia: "The insolvency of Romcab is a loss both for the economy of the county of Mureș, as well as for the national economy "
       For the economy to grow, we need as many privatizations on the stock exchange as possible, listings of great companies and a sustained education at the national level, so that the investment in the...  details
04.05.2017
FINANCIAL EDUCATION FOR BANKERS
     Valentin Lazea, the chief-economist of the NBR, is making progress, setting foot into cultural territory.
     In a speech at the Cristian Popișteanu symposium of April 26th, 2017, Valentin Lazea noted...  details
03.05.2017
AN EXPLANATION ON BITCOIN AND THE FUTURE OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOOGIES
     The blockchain technology is part of a recent technological revolution, started in 2008 with the alternative currency bitcoin. In the aftermath of the appearance of p2p programs (such as...  details
28.04.2017
ILAN LAUFER, MMACA:
     * The Start Up Nation program is set to be approved in the Parliament
       Taxes that can't be paid online will not be paid at all, Ilan Laufer, state secretary in the Ministry for the Business Environment, Trade and Entrepreneurship (MMACA), who mentioned that by...  details
.