Conferința BURSA - Dezvoltarea Romaniei 2018
TUDOR TATU, THE UNION OF BANKING MEDIATORS:
BURSA 14.01.2013

ELENA VOINEA (Translated by Cosmin Ghidoveanu)
 
mărește imaginea
Tudor Tatu
       Requests for banking mediation received and solved by the Union of Banking Mediators fell over 90% last year, said Tudor Tatu, the president of the Union of Banking Mediators, in an interview. He explained that in 2011 the Union of Banking Mediators has solved over 500 requests, whereas in 2012 that number fell to 38, of which more than half were denied. The large number of requests for mediation recorded in 2011 came as a result of the introduction of the Government Emergency Ordinance 50/2010, which led to the creation of the conflicts between banks and their customers, according to Tudor Tatu.
       For now, mediation has failed to be perceived as an effective solution to the conflicts between banks and their customers, he mentioned. Still, the mediators who are the members of the Union of Banking Mediators, who succeeded in getting the parties of banking lawsuit together for mediation, have a success percentage of approximately 25%, which is considered a good outcome, compared to the specific of the dispute, according to the president of the Union.

 
     Reporter: What is the form banking mediation currently takes in Romania?
     Tudor Tatu: Since its creation, the Union of the Banking Mediators has constantly taken steps to promote mediation among the customers of banking or non-banking institutions (IFN), as well as among the employees of the latter, using various channels accessible for information.
     However, the banking cases are just another segment of disputes which are hard to access by mediators, but an approach adapted to the rigors of the financial-banking system can ensure a positive response in a not so far future.
     As the disputes between banks and their customers are many, mediation failed for now to be perceived as an efficient alternative to the conflicts of this kind.
     However, the members of the Union of Banking Mediators who have succeeded in bringing the parties of a mediation party in, have a success percentage of approximately 25%, which is considered to be very good in relation to the specific of the dispute.
     Bank cases have a specific nature, especially due to the fact that the representatives of the banking institutions can only make decisions during mediation within the limits of the mandate they have received. From this point of view, standard mediation has little chance of working, and this is caused by the fact that banks have created internal regulations to the representative which comes to the mediation.
     It is noteworthy that, after the years where "ID-card-only loans" were all the rage and lenders would share the glory of loans denominated in Swiss Francs or Japanese yen, the time has come to pay them back. The first stages for the recovery of the claims are handled within the bank, rather than through mediation, as some of the banks intend to resort to debt collectors for this segment. As for late recovery, more than two thirds of the banks prefer to outsource the troubled loans instead of attempting to mediate with the clients. Bankers are thus looking for a way to "clean up" their balance sheet, which is a practice which is used constantly.
     As I've said ever since the creation of the Union of Banking Mediators, there will come a time when legislative changes will clip the banks' wings, reducing their domination over their customers. The rules of the game have changed starting with January 9th, 2013, after the coming into effect of the new Civil Procedure Code. Customers and banks will be required to go to a banking mediator first. New lawsuits will no longer be admitted unless the plaintiffs prove first that they have participated in a mediation session.
     The litigants who are customers of banks or lenders, will be forced to participate in a meeting for information about mediation, before going to court, regardless of whether they are individuals or companies. Failing to follow this procedure will be punished according to an emergency ordinance passed by the Government in its meeting of December 12th, 2012, with their lawsuit being rejected.
     Reporter: Are you considering the creation of an institution for mediators?
     Tudor Tatu: I can say that we are, leaving aside the law which governs mediation at the present time, by which any mediator can mediate anything and anywhere and going on the principle that "anything that the law does not prohibit or stipulate" is allowed.
     The first step we took by creating the Union of Bank Mediators starting from the premise that the area of mediation of financial-banking litigations is one that, aside from the know-how and abilities obtained following the pursuit of the mediation courses, the people who pursue their activity in this area need to have legal and banking procedure know-how, to know the scheme of the banking system, to be permanently informed about banking products, the procedure for their selling and recouping and the legislation of the banking sector.
     In my opinion, any activity is productive when it is conducted in an institutionalized manner.
     There have been voices among mediators and at the level of the Mediation Council which are saying that in the case of banking litigation one can resort to any authorized mediator to solve the dispute. This is wrong! In my opinion, mediation in the financial-banking sector must be done in an institutionalized manner and by specialized mediators.
     Reporter: How is the cooperation between the NBR and the Romanian Banking Association going when it comes to the banking mediation?
     Tudor Tatu: I can say that we have a good cooperation. Both the Romanian Banking Association and the NBR are making efforts to introduce mediation in the banking system, but unfortunately it has been found that neither banks nor their customers are in the habit of using the procedure of mediation.
     The Romanian Banking Association, together with the Union of Banking Mediators, is one of the promoters of banking mediation.
     With the support of the Romanian Banking Association and of the Romanian Banking Institute (IBR) we have trained classes of students in banking mediation, both from the ranks of members of the Union of Banking Mediators, or from among other mediators who wanted to remain independent.
     The Romanian Banking Association even sent a letter to the banking system saying that it would be a good thing for it to cooperate with the specialized mediators to reduce the number of cases that reach the courts, because many of them have no justification for doing so.
     As for the cooperation with the NBR it is important to mention that, in the month of September 2012, the Romanian Government issued an ordinance which amended several laws concerning payment services, including some of the articles of the Government Emergency Ordinance 113/2009, the Law 127/2011 and Government Decision 1259/2010. The goal of the ordinance was to set up the procedure of mediation, as regulated by the Law 192/2006 concerning mediation and the organization of the mediator profession, with the subsequent amendments and modifications, as a procedure for solving the litigations in the financial payments services outside the court, in consensus with the mechanisms implemented on a national level in other sectors of the financial services and the elimination of the involvement of the National Bank of Romania in this matter.
     Therefore, the law has amended art. 179 of the Emergency Government Ordinance 113/2009 concerning payment services, by replacing the attributions of the National Bank of Romania to solve the litigations between the users and the providers of payment services using the procedure of mediation, outside the courts, with the appropriate adaptation of other legal dispositions which refer to it.
     As a provision of a temporary nature, the Ordinance comprises the fact that the requests for the solving of the National Bank of Romania, by the time the emergency ordinance came into effect, will be solved according to the procedure in effect until that date, and afterwards, by the mediators specializing in solving bank litigations.
     So far, no such requests have been sent, but as such requests get sent to the NBR, due to lack of information, the NBR will distribute them to the Union of Banking mediators to be competently solved, through mediation.
     The ordinance has been published in the Official Gazette, and since the date of its publication it has relieved the NBR from the task of dealing with the complaints.
     Reporter: What are the aspects which you would enumerate to improve the institution of banking mediation?
     Tudor Tatu: As a mediator, who knows quite well the financial-banking system, I would come up with mediation formulas which would answer to this type of cases, with new methods for solving them. One of the options would be the method MED-CON (Mediation - Counseling) and which can be successfully used in these cases.
     This method involves the starting of the mediation procedure, and if the mediation fails it leads to the second step, which is conciliation.
     A second method which I would introduce in the law, would be the MED- ARB method (Mediation-Arbitrage). If the mediation fails, then the arbitrage goes ahead, and it does not go to court, this being the last thing to resort to if both options failed.
     Another aspect would be the introduction in the law of the evaluation mediation, which allows the mediator to assess the lawsuit without the presence of the parties being needed, using the data in the documents and issuing a recommendation which the parties may or may not follow, like they agree.
     Aside from the presented technical aspects, there is also the involvement of the decision-making factors in the Mediation Council in promoting mediation in the financial-banking system and elsewhere, which so far has left a lot to be desired, as the members of the Board of Mediation focusing on promoting their own training schools and on the inclusion in the mediation law of the conflict of interest which would eliminate the access to these positions of mediators which are trainers or manage formation schools.
     Reporter: How did applications for the school of banking mediation evolve in 2012?
     Tudor Tatu: Whereas in 2011, the members of the Union of Banking Mediators have solved over 500 applications, most of them receiving a positive answer, at the level of 2012 a decrease was seen, to just 38 requests on a national level, of which more than half received a negative response, either due to the refusal of the representatives of the bank to show up for mediation, or tardiness, or due to non-confirmation.
     Reporter: What expectations do you have in 2013 for banking mediation?
     Tudor Tatu: I hope that 2013 will bring added value to the institution of mediation, and the litigants, whether they are customers, or lenders, will understand that it is better for them to use the procedure of mediation in the arguments that arise, rather than resorting to the Consumer Protection Agency (ANPC) or to the courts. But most of all, I wish for banks to comply with the legal provisions, to eliminate by themselves the abusive clauses which still exist in some lending contracts, to forget about making up all kinds of commissions and to be more forgiving with the troubled customers who lost their jobs due to restructuring, bankruptcies, mergers, etc.
     Reporter: Which complaints do customers make the most often?
     Tudor Tatu: The one conflict that was the most prevalent has been and I think will continue to be that of the introduction in the loan agreements of abusive clauses and of hidden commissions.
     The latest complaints concerned the charging of a commission upon cashing in, which is completely illegal.
     Reporter: What are the benefits of the mediation process?
     Tudor Tatu: A good synonym for financial-banking mediation would be a mechanism for avoiding and reducing financial collapse, and it consists of an agreement between the debtor and the creditors on the manner in which the distressed debtor will pay off its debts.
     The debtor is supposed to announce its creditors early about the difficulties it is facing and to grant them the chance to recover, thus proposing a concrete and coherent plan for reorganization for that purpose.
     The creditors need to be persuaded to accept the proposed plan, as well as the fact that they could get more money in the event of an agreement between them, occurring at the end of the mediation procedure, than in the event of insolvency, bankruptcy or foreclosure.
     Only if the mediation procedure fails and a compromise isn't reached through it, does the process move into insolvency, bankruptcy or foreclosure.
     In order to begin the mediation procedure, the creditor or the debtor can ask a mediator to begin the mediation procedure, a member of the Union of Banking Mediators who in turn will ask for the agreement of the other party.
     Once the party which received the request has given its approval through the signing of the agreement, the mediator will begin the mediation procedure. If the party whose approval was asked does not agree, the mediation is considered as not having been accepted.
     When both parties want or plan to follow the procedure of mediation, the creditor and the debtor choose one or more mediators through mutual agreement, members of the Union of Banking Mediators ands based on their written agreement, the mediation procedure gets started.
     The fee of the mediator will be set through negotiation with the debtor and the creditor, taking into account the complexity of the lawsuit, the time allocated, the number of sessions, the amount of the lawsuit, etc. and will be borne by the parties equally or according to their agreement.
     Unless the law stipulates differently, the parties - banks' customers or the banks - can resort to mediation before or after the beginning of the insolvency procedure or the foreclosure stage, before the competent courts, thus agreeing to solve in this manner any conflicts arising from the loan contracts.
     Whereas throughout mediation, a situation which would affect its purpose, the neutrality or the impartiality of the mediator were to arise, then the mediator is expected to announce it to the representatives of the creditor and of the debtor, which would decide on whether to maintain or denounce the mediation contract.
     Once the creditor and the debtor have reached an agreement, a written agreement is drafted, which will comprise all the clauses they have agreed to, based on which, at the headquarters of the creditor, an appendix to the initial loan agreement would be drafted, as applicable, which would need to be honored by the debtor and the creditor alike, being no longer subject to authentication by the notary public or to verification by the court, as the case may be.
     Reporter: What does banking mediation look like in the countries of the European Union? How often is mediation resorted to in the European countries, and what are the results?
     Tudor Tatu: The Union of Banking Mediators has the expertise of banking mediation at the level of the European Union, because in the beginning of January we have begun the steps for the union to become a member of the FIN - NET (Financial Dispute Resolution Network) of the European Commission, together with the 56 member entities originating 24 EU member states and the European economic area, and as part of the meeting of March of 2011, which was held in Brussels, the Union has officially submitted its candidacy by becoming a candidate member.
     Out of the relationship with the other partners and their exposures as part of the works of the plenums we have had the opportunity to find out that at the level of the other European countries, banking mediation operates through the banking Ombudsmen created through decisions of the governments of the EU member states, or by the associations of the banks, but in compliance with their independence or impartiality.
     As for the costs of mediation in the European countries, they are supported by either the state or by the banks through the creation of a common fund handled by the banks' association.
     On a European level, Greece holds the number one spot in terms of the number of disputes solved through litigation, followed by Italy, England, Spain and Austria, but the systems are so well implemented that the outcome of the mediation is positive most of the time.
     Malta also has a very well developed banking mediation system, which is achieved through the Malta Financial Services Authority (MFSA) and which has solved a considerable number of applications.
     Reporter: Thank you! 

     The fee of the mediator will be set through negotiation with the debtor and the creditor, taking into account the complexity of the lawsuit, the time allocated, the number of sessions, the amount of lawsuits, etc. and it will be borne by the parties equally or according to their agreement.
     
     At the level of the other European countries, banking mediation operates through the banking Ombudsmen created through decisions of the governments of the EU member states, or by the associations of the banks. (...) On a European level, Greece holds the number one spot in terms of the number of disputes solved through litigation.

 
 

 
Readers' comments    [ add a comment ] 
Trimite părerea ta.
Nume (maxim 50 caractere)
E-mail (optional)
Titlu (maxim 50 caractere)
Mesaj
 
REGULAMENTUL MESAJELOR
Acord
Prin trimiterea opiniei ne confirmați că ați citit regulamentul de mai sus și că vă asumați prevederile sale !
Aceeasi sectiune (English Section)
BECAUSE AN AGREEMENT ON THE PRICE COULDN'T BE REACHED,
Ediții precedente
Newsletter Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn RSS
Jurnal Bursier
21.09.2018
BVB
     * Rulaj de 47 milioane de lei, peste media anului
     
     Piața principală a Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a încheiat ședința de tranzacționare de joi preponderent în teritoriul pozitiv, opt dintre...  click să citești tot articolul
20.09.2018
BVB
     * Scădere de 0,53% pentru BET-NG
     
     Volumul de tranzacționare înregistrat în ședința de la mijlocul săptămânii a Bursei de Valori București (BVB) a fost de 33,45 milioane de lei, dintre care...  click să citești tot articolul
20.09.2018
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Bursele din Europa au urcat ieri, pe fondul câștigurilor din sectorul materiilor prime.  click să citești tot articolul
19.09.2018
BVB
     * Toți indicii bursieri au închis în creștere
     * Tranzacții cu aproape 3% din MedLife, efectuate pe piața "deal"
     
     Lichiditatea înregistrată în ședința de tranzacționare de ieri la...  click să citești tot articolul
19.09.2018
BURSELE DIN LUME
     Piețele europene au urmat un curs mixt ieri, după ce administrația americană a decis să impună taxe vamale de 10% pe importuri chinezești de 200 de miliarde de dolari.  click să citești tot articolul
18.09.2018
BVB
     * Rulaj de 42 milioane de lei, în apropierea mediei acestui an
     
     Cinci dintre cei nouă indici ai Bursei de Valori București (BVB) au încheiat prima ședință de tranzacționare a săptămânii ușor în...  click să citești tot articolul
Cotații Internaționale

Curs Valutar

Curs valabil din data de 21 septembrie 2018
1 Dolar australian...
1 Leva bulgărească...
1 Dolar canadian....
1 Franc elvețian...
1 Coroană cehă...
1 Coroană daneză...
1 Liră egipteană...
1 Euro...
1 Liră sterlină...
100 Forinți maghiari...
100 Yeni japonezi...
1 Leu moldovenesc...
1 Coroană norvegiană...
1 Zlot polonez...
1 Rublă rusească...
1 Coroană suedeză...
1 Liră turcească...
1 Dolar S.U.A...
1 Rand sud-african...
1 Real brazilian...
1 Renminbi chinezesc...
1 Rupie indiană...
100 Woni sud-coreeni...
1 Peso mexican...
1 Dolar neo-zeelandez...
1 Dinar sârbesc...
1 Hryvna ucraineană...
1 Dirham emirate arabe...
1 Kuna croată...
1 Bahtul thailandez...
1 Gram aur...
1 DST...
AUD
BGN
CAD
CHF
CZK
DKK
EGP
EUR
GBP
HUF
JPY
MDL
NOK
PLN
RUB
SEK
TRY
USD
ZAR
BRL
CNY
INR
KRW
MXN
NZD
RSD
UAH
AED
HRK
THB
XAU
XDR
2.8801
2.3806
3.0614
4.1351
0.1822
0.6242
0.2206
4.6559
5.2123
1.4386
3.5050
0.2364
0.4852
1.0851
0.0595
0.4496
0.6306
3.9517
0.2773
0.9692
0.5774
0.0547
0.3541
0.2093
2.6455
0.0394
0.1409
1.0759
0.6269
0.1220
153.4508
5.5550
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
..Lei
click aici pentru cursurile pieței valutare - istoric
English Section
14.09.2018
MREPORT BY TRANSPARENCY INTERNATIONAL
     Globalization has also brought with it an unpleasant effect: cross-border corruption. According to the intermediate report Exporting Corruption for the year 2018, a document drawn up by the organization Transparency International, there is a practice among powerful foreign companies of bribing the public servants of another country when they want to enter the local market.  click here to read the entire article
07.09.2018
DEPUTY VIRGIL POPESCU, VICEPRESIDENT OF THE COMMISSION FOR INDUSTRIES AND SERVICES
     The offshore law will once again reach the Commission, in one or two weeks, according to Mr. Virgil Popescu, the vice-president of the Commission for Industries and Services, the Chamber of Deputies.  click here to read the entire article
05.09.2018
MRS. FIREA'S VERBAL BOMBS
     * "There have been attempts for the prefect to be made a scapegoat"
     * "The support from the government wasn't much to talk about, so if it were withdrawn, there wouldn't be much of a difference"
     Bucharest's General Mayor was heard on Tuesday as a witness by the prosecutors of the General Prosecutor's Office in the case concerning the events which happened on August 10th in Victoriei Square. Before going into the Prosecutors' Department building, Gabriela Firea said she stood by her statements made immediately after the meeting of the National Executive Committee of the PSD and said: "I always speak based on facts, not just in this particular case, but in other areas as well, including politics. I will be answering to the questions of the prosecutor who contacted me and told me I was supposed to be heard in the case which is now being investigated concerning the intervention of the gendarmes on August 10th".  click here to read the entire article
31.08.2018
     The particularly hot weather and the conditions of extreme draught in Europe have brought to light terrible warnings from the past.
     Associated Press recently wrote that in the riverbed of the Elba in the Czech Republic have resurfaced the giant stones known as "the hunger stones", which have indicated over time, the coming of hard times.
     "When you see me, weep", is written on one of these stones, which seems to be considered the best hydrological benchmark in Europe. The inscription is in German and dates back to 1616.
     A detailed analysis of the stone inscriptions was published by the Czech researchers in the "Climate of the Past" magazine in 2013 (author's note: "Droughts in the Czech Lands, 1090-2012 AD", April 2013).  click here to read the entire article
29.08.2018
     * Claudiu Cazacu, XTB România: "United States companies have posted results that even exceeded the analysts' expectations, which were already for 2-figure profit increases"
     * Liviu Moldovan, financial analyst: "Currently, investors have a «blind» faith in the stock markets, in general, and in that of the US, in particular"
     For the first time in the history of the American markets, Nasdaq has surpassed the psychological level of 8,000 points.
     In the August 27 session, the Standard & Poor's 500 (S&P 500) index also reached an all time high, ending the trading session at almost 2,897 points.  click here to read the entire article
27.08.2018
     The capital market was marked, last week, by a number of controversial statements tied to the listing of Digi Communications, starting from the statements made recently by Darius Vâlcov, state advisor on the team of the prime-minister, who wrote on his Facebook page that he has asked the Financial Oversight Authority (ASF) if it was true that the book value of the Digi shares was 1 leu and 8 bani, and pointed out that at the time of the IPO, the shares of Digi were listed at 40 lei and are currently priced at 28 lei (30% down) and keep going down.  click here to read the entire article
23.08.2018
     Angela Merkel inaugurated the highway in December 2005, less than a month after she became chancellor of Germany.
     The highway was built on the territory of the former East Germany, connects Lubeck and the Polish border, after the junction with A11, and goes through the electoral precinct of chancellor Merkel.  click here to read the entire article
20.08.2018
THE NATIONAL MINERAL RESOURCES AGENCY, IN A NOTIFICATION TO THE PRIME-MINISTER:
     The Romanian government has lost over 8 billion lei, between 2006-2018, following the failure to update the royalties paid by the oil and gas companies, says Gigi Dragomir, the president of the National Mineral Resources Agency (ANRM), in a report sent to the prime-minister.  click here to read the entire article
15.08.2018
      * (Interview with Radu Grațian Ghețea, President - CEO of CEC Bank)
     In banking there are many risks and that is why banks need to be flexible and have as diverse an exposure as possible, which take the market circumstances at the time into account, says Radu Grațian Ghețea, President and CEO of CEC Bank. He told us, in an interview: "We have to adapt to what is happening in the market and we need to do things in such a way that the economic activity and that of the bank both function properly. If we're going with the idea that we want to eliminate every risk, then we'll just stop doing anything. For instance, we have been and we are a bank which heavily funds agriculture, which also means animal husbandry. A few years ago, our exposure to the aviculture sector was rather significant, and when the avian flu came we had to cover some non-performing loans on that segment. Now that the avian flu is done, we are facing the swine flu. What should we do, stop lending?"
     Reporter: Lately, there have been opinions from some experts who are saying that there is a wave of non-performing loans of the ones taken out by the First Home Program. What is your comment on these statements?  click here to read the entire article
08.08.2018
     * (Interview with Laszlo Diosi, OTP Bank CEO)
     Reporter: How would you describe the banking market, at the present time?
     Laszlo Diosi: Even though there are plenty of challenges, there are also many opportunities for the Romanian banking system. The lessons of the financial-economic crisis have resulted in a better regulated framework, stable, transparent and predictable. The guiding line of the policies developed by the authorities that are qualified, but in particular by those with a regulatory and oversight role has been characterized by a balance between profitability and systemic safety.
     But there is no shortage of challenges. We are talking here about challenges which concern the digitalization of the banking system and the national and international legislation. The entire system needs to align with complex and sometimes confused regulations.
     Recorded by Emilia Olescu  click here to read the entire article
31.07.2018
     * (Interview with Dan Paul, the president of the Association of Brokers)
     The management of the Bucharest Stock Exchange (BVB) needs to find out from brokers whether Romania truly needs a derivatives market, says Dan Paul, the president of the Association of Brokers, who was kind enough to grant BURSA an interview.  click here to read the entire article
27.07.2018
THE DĂNCILĂ GOVERNMENT AFTER SIX MONTHS
     Now we know why prime-minister Dăncilă was in a hurry to announce the activity report for the first six months at the helm of the Romanian government: the nice tale of the hike of pensions and salaries wasn't supposed to be overshadowed by the evolution of budget expenses, whose increase has led the deficit of the consolidated general budget to 1.61% of the GDP, from 0.88% after the first five months of the year.  click here to read the entire article
23.07.2018
BECAUSE AN AGREEMENT ON THE PRICE COULDN'T BE REACHED,
     The public offer started by Vimetco and Conef for a stake of at most 53.77% of the shares of Alro Slatina (Alro) has been unsuccessful, as the issuer announced that due to the unfavorable market conditions, the shareholders, company and underwriters couldn't agree on a price for the volume of 383.79 million shares put up for sale.  click here to read the entire article
23.07.2018
ECONOMIC ANALYST AURELIAN DOCHIA PREDICTS:
     * According to Eurostat, Romania has the biggest governmental deficit in the EU
     The hike of some taxes, in the near future, is unavoidable, according to economic analyst Aurelian Dochia.
     His statement comes as, in the first quarter, the government's deficit has seen an increase over the last quarter of 2017, according to data by the European Statistics Office (Eurostat).  click here to read the entire article
13.07.2018
Russia World Cup
     The final tournament of the World Football Cup will end with a gala representation, the duel between Croatia and France. France, the with the most expensive players in the tournament, has met the expectations, Croatia is the biggest surprise the of the competition.  click here to read the entire article
.