OVIDIU DEMETRESCU, ARBA:"It is obvious that the managers of Electrica have not complied with the law"

ADINA ARDELEANU (translated by Cosmin Ghidoveanu)
English Section / 18 octombrie 2017

"It is obvious that the managers of Electrica have not complied with the law"

The management of the company accepted two applications that were sent in late, for the elections of October 26th, claiming they were submitted "within reasonable delays"

"I think that we are embarrassing ourselves, by the mere fact that we were able to interpret the law in such a way", said Ovidiu Demetrescu

"Demetrescu: "ASF and BVB should react, in the case of Electrica, if they had a management with a free spirit"

The directors of "Electrica" (EL) violated the law when accepting the applications backed by the government for the elections of the new management, recorded eight minutes after the deadline from the convening notice, claiming they were submitted "within a reasonable delay", says Ovidiu Demetrescu, the president of the Romanian Association for Good Management (Asociaţia Română de Bună Administrare - ARBA).

He raised a warning about the return to the practice of political appointments in state-owned companies and the failure to honor the promises from the prospectus for the listing of the company.

In his opinion, the Financial Oversight Authority (ASF), the regulator of the stock market, needs to issue a verdict in this case.

On Friday, Electrica announced that there are nine candidates who submitted applications for the elections of the Board of Directors, aside from the current ones. The nine applications that have been accepted are Doina Elena Dascălu and Constantin Ciprian lacob. The candidacy of Alexandru Botez and of Gabriel Dumitraşcu, the former head of the Energy privatizations department, which were also submitted after the deadline were not accepted.

"The situation at Electrica seems unprecedented to me", said Ovidiu Demetrescu, who added: "We are talking about a listed company, where are taking place a completely illegal intervention and interpretation of the law by the Board of Electrica. According to the law, there is no «reasonable delay». When there is a deadline set in the convening notice, it is set in stone».

If one goes to the train station at 12:10, and the train leaves at 12:00, we can't just hop on board as the train is running".

He also mentioned the attempt to appoint politically-affiliated managers in state owned companies: "And here we are, after the example of Electrica, we are no longer referring to those companies in which the state is a 100% shareholder. We are now dealing with a listed company, in which the state holds less than 30% of these shares. With that stake, the government should be a minority shareholder, but it is the biggest shareholder. Thus, at Electrica, the state ends up having the power of a majority shareholder, because in the General Shareholder Meeting we have generally seen a quorum of 70-75%, in which the holding of the state represents a very clear majority".

Gabriel Dumitraşcu criticized the intention to politicize the management of Electrica and notified the ASF about the failure to comply with the deadline set in the he convening notice for submitting new applications for the new board. Mr. Demetrescu commented: "At this time, through the action and the voice of Mr. Gabriel Dumitraşcu once again the issue of the politicizing of companies in the portfolio of the state has appeared, especially the ones in the energy sector, and we think that this does not bode well.

At a certain time, Gabriel Dumitraşcu was the head of the privatizations department in the Ministry of Energy. At the time, one of the promises that Romania made was to depoliticize the management of companies and to move forward with good corporate governance. That's where the selection of independent managers began, in small steps.

Today we are seeing that this promise has been scrapped and we are returning to old practices to politicize management, which I don't think will yield the expected results".

Ovidiu Demetrescu stressed that Electrica is listed both in Bucharest and London, and in the listing prospectus, the company made some promises: "One of the most important promises, which was given a lot of weight at the time of the IPO, was the implementation of corporate governance.

Through politicization, we are doing nothing else than violate the provisions of the prospectus, and somehow, try to cheat the investors who bought shares based on the prospectus presented by the company.

We are not allowed to do that and I strongly believe that the Financial Oversight Authority needs to state its opinion on the compliance with the law in this case.

It is clearly a matter of failure to comply with the law and good corporate governance.

If the delay is accepted for some applicants, then all applications should be accepted. If not, the company will have to issue a new convening notice and hold the General Shareholder Meeting at a subsequent date".

When asked why he believed that Electrica accepted the delayed candidacies, when it could have held the elections in another General Shareholder Meeting, Ovidiu Demetrescu said: "In my opinion, there are two possible answers. One reason would be incompetence and I find it very hard to believe that the people who lead Electrica do not know the law and were unable to consult with their legal team, who could have told them that something like that was not in compliance with the law.

They probably answered to some political pressure. That is a suspicion. I think that they would be the most qualified to say why they acted the way they did. But it is obvious they broke the law. There is no derogation, within the meaning of the law, from a deadline. There is no stock market in the world that something like this has happened. Deadlines are very strict. I think that we are being embarrassed, even by the mere fact that we could even consider such an interpretation of a law.

We need to have professionals on the Boards of Directors, in full knowledge of the law and who ask their legal advisors when they don't know something.

Also, we need to look at people and especially at their ethics and integrity.

Perhaps we should have an independent body that can say whether a person is qualified in terms of ethics and integrity.

I know that at one time, there was an initiative from Electrica together with Transparency International, to make all the processes more transparent, an «integrity warning».

Also, I think that the Ministry of Energy should analyze the profiles of the candidates it has proposed, compared to the needs of the company".

Mr. Demetrescu addsed that even though the ASF has a management politically appointed by the parliament, it is an institution that has some regulations according to which it operates: "The management of the ASF needs to have a perfectly professional behavior that fits the institution it is in charge of. Even though the bosses of the ASF are appointed by a party, they need to have an independent and professional behavior when it comes to the capital market that they are regulating.

We are waiting for the answer of the ASF, as well as that of the Ministry of Energy".

Ovidiu Demtrescu thinks that the BSE should also react, in the case of Electrica, "if it had a management with a free spirit".

In the opinion of the president of ARBA, the election of a new management at Electrica, in the General Shareholder Meeting, would have negative consequences, because it could go as far as the decision being invalidated in court, which would lead to the company losing its credibility and subsequently, investors' confidence.

Mr. Demetrescu thinks that major institutional investors in Electrica should take a stance on the compliance with corporate governance and the law, if they want the company to perform.

ARBA is a non-profit organization which plans to promote the position of administrator, member on the Board of Directors/Supervisory Board, Directorate or other management structures.

The mission of ARBA is to build and develop a Center for Excellence which would create and promote responsible and ethical business standards, for the benefit of the business community, as well as of the overall Romanian society.

Răzvan Nicolescu: "Companies shouldn't be changed into appendixes or political party structures"

Former energy minister expressed concern over the situation of political appointments in state-owned companies, after the BURSA newspaper reported that the state was late in submitting two applications for the new management of Electrica, which were accepted, while the rest of the nominations were rejected.

Răzvan Nicolescu told "BURSA" the following: "I am concerned over the quality of the appointments in state owned companies. State owned companies are and have to remain the property of the Romanian state. They mustn't be turned into appendixes or political party structures. Romania can't afford to go backwards by many years!".

The ASF told Gabriel Dumitraşcu that he would review the situation at Electrica

The Financial Oversight Authority (ASF) is analyzing the situation at Electrica, upon notification from Gabriel Dumitraşcu, according to a reply that was sent to him.

Gabriel Dumitraşcu criticized the intention of politicizing the management of Electrica and notified the ASF about the violation of the deadline from the convening notice for the submission of applications for the new management, by the Romanian state.

Gabriel Dumitraşcu wrote on his Facebook page: "My respect for the ASF !

A few minutes ago I received the following message:


Concerning your message and the aspects reported through Facebook, as well as through the complaint sent directly to the ASF, they are being investigated, and upon the completion of that probe the appropriate actions will be taken. Thank you».

Thank the ASF for the quick reaction.

As I have already said in the previous messages, I trust the authorities of the state! The slip-ups, which sometimes happen, are caused by the incompetent people or by mistakes".

Alexandru Botez: "All of the people who committed these transgressions need to go!"

Alexandru Botez thinks that the rejection of his application for the elections for the Board of Directors of "Electrica" represents an abuse and that he will use all the legal avenues to get justice, and demands that all those who have committed abuse should quickly resign.

He made the following statement yesterday: "I officially saw that they have excluded me from the list of candidates. This is an abuse! Things won't stay this way! I will use all the legal avenues to do justice! An organizations without principles and rules is an organizations that will collapse quickly! No one is above rules and the law. All those who placed themselves above the law and have committed this abuse must leave quickly from the positions they hold!".

Cotaţii Internaţionale

vezi aici mai multe cotaţii

Bursa Construcţiilor


Videoconferinţa “Digitalizarea României”

Curs valutar BNR

05 Aug. 2022
Euro (EUR)Euro4.9264
Dolar SUA (USD)Dolar SUA4.8175
Franc elveţian (CHF)Franc elveţian5.0450
Liră sterlină (GBP)Liră sterlină5.8439
Gram de aur (XAU)Gram de aur276.7076

convertor valutar


mai multe cotaţii valutare

Cotaţii Emitenţi BVB
Bursele din regiune
Cotaţii fonduri mutuale
Teatrul Național I. L. Caragiale Bucuresti
Carte - Golden calf - the meaning of interest rate
Carte - The crisis solution terminus a quo